Search found 23 matches

by BusError
18 June 2026, 20:52
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?
Replies: 2
Views: 214

Re: Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?

I was told today that I am notorious on the forums for being rude. If you're interested in using chop moves come find out how rude I am! :geek:
by BusError
18 June 2026, 20:40
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Physical vs. online hanabi
Replies: 10
Views: 418

Re: Physical vs. online hanabi

I've played in person ~100 times or so, with different groups who come from BGA or HG or neither. Sometimes I try to teach the simplest subset of the BGA conventions, sometimes we make up something new. My personal favorite game with some family we use chop focus for all clues, with saves for all cl...
by BusError
18 June 2026, 20:34
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Removing conventions from the help page
Replies: 2
Views: 141

Re: Removing conventions from the help page

This skip advice is really poor, I agree Malo. It's one of the hardest things to fix after someone gets the idea that "skip = play". It hamstrings the team from collaboratively managing discards, and it makes stall techniques harder (like double discard avoidance). Or, at the very least, &...
by BusError
21 February 2026, 18:48
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: how about this 3 clue
Replies: 4
Views: 136

Re: how about this 3 clue

This is one of those things that varies between groups, but I would say BGA generally biases toward assuming playable clue versus longer finesse. HG is the opposite, as I understand it, you'd have to assume this could be either 3R or 3Y and delay/discard until that clarifies itself.
by BusError
02 February 2026, 21:19
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?
Replies: 2
Views: 214

Re: Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?

I don't know if this forum bumps threads to the top based on replies, but we've had some fun games with the crew so far. If anyone else is interested in joining, please check us out!
by BusError
21 January 2026, 22:00
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: What happened in this game?
Replies: 4
Views: 284

Re: What happened in this game?

Every time I watch a replay I'm reminded that some people don't use stacked view.

Pretty obvious they are cheating, no other way to interpret this.
by BusError
14 January 2026, 14:23
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: 2 player ELO level separation
Replies: 12
Views: 311

Re: 2 player ELO level separation

Probably they should just get rid of ELO and show number of games played by table size / variant. Hanab.live does this and it makes a lot more sense.

@Blacktango: I get that this would break their model either way. Fortunately they have some programmers ;-)
by BusError
13 January 2026, 02:39
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?
Replies: 2
Views: 214

Chop Moves on BGA - Anyone interested?

Hey all - I've been playing H-Group conventions a bit lately and it's left me wanting to try Chop Moves with the normal BGA conventions. I wrote up a doc here about how I think they could be incorporated. If you're interested, join the BGA Group -- when I see enough players online I'll try to start ...
by BusError
06 January 2026, 18:16
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Bluff during Layer
Replies: 4
Views: 155

Re: Bluff during Layer

Thanks all. What I'm hearing is this isn't consistent here on BGA. I find both sides of this reasonable. Unfortunately, the player in question told me they would have to RT thumb since I didn't understand this basic, obvious and universally shared principle. Bummer.
by BusError
01 January 2026, 22:37
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Bluff during Layer
Replies: 4
Views: 155

Bluff during Layer

Bob has 2y Xx [1y] Xx [1r]. Charlie has Xx 2w Xx 3y 4y. Alice clues Y to Charlie, indicating 3y is playable, following a blind-play of 2y. On the following turn, Bob draws 1b. Charlie discards Xx and draws Xx. Alice clues W to Charlie. Should Bob play the newly drawn card, or continue the layer first?

Go to advanced search