Search found 102 matches

by mturton
12 November 2025, 15:06
Forum: Catan
Topic: For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player counts?
Replies: 13
Views: 330

Re: For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player count

The fight over the best spaces is why I like 4 player the best. Spot on. The limited space is what makes Catan shine. It makes it necessary to trade and co-operate and it's what makes it possible to threaten and block. Playing 3 players on the standard board is basically just pick the best numbers ...
by mturton
05 November 2025, 14:40
Forum: Catan
Topic: For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player counts?
Replies: 13
Views: 330

For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player counts?

The truth is that four players on the tiny map is a terrible game. Usually two players are instantly screwed as soon as all the settlements are placed. Most of the time a third player can make a pretense of being competitive, but actually they are foredoomed as well. The result is for 2 players the ...
by mturton
03 October 2025, 14:29
Forum: "Alpha" games
Topic: Top 5 New games wanted: BZ
Replies: 1271
Views: 182452

Re: Top 5 New games wanted: BZ

1. Marvel Legendary
2. Lands of Galzyr
3. Anno 1800
4. Star Trek: Captain's Chair
5. Imperium Classic + expansions
by mturton
24 August 2025, 12:10
Forum: "Alpha" games
Topic: Top 5 New games wanted: BZ
Replies: 1271
Views: 182452

Re: Top 5 New games wanted: BZ

Kingdom legacy + Expansions
Star Trek: Captain's Chair
Anno 1800 + Expansions
Vantage
by mturton
02 August 2025, 14:15
Forum: Suggestions
Topic: Games wanted for BGA / Jeux demandés sur BGA
Replies: 2361
Views: 489253

Re: Games wanted for BGA / Jeux demandés sur BGA

Star Trek Captain's Chair.
by mturton
21 October 2024, 13:18
Forum: Beyond the Sun
Topic: No cards visible problem
Replies: 0
Views: 199

No cards visible problem

Whenever my wife opens this game, none of the cards are displayed on either the technology tree or the Galaxy or the victory conditions. She cannot see any Technologies or planets. Everything is black. The technology trees look like the level 4 Technologies at the beginning of the game with the disp...
by mturton
04 July 2024, 14:13
Forum: Discussions
Topic: BGA - please stop the Arena madness
Replies: 17
Views: 1160

Re: BGA - please stop the Arena madness

BGA clearly doesnt care whether players participate in Arena, or it would have a more sensible and inclusive Arena system.
by mturton
10 April 2024, 04:00
Forum: Discussions
Topic: Reconsider Arena Rankings System
Replies: 68
Views: 3662

Re: Reconsider Arena Rankings System

Losses are punished more heavily the higher your rating. At low ratings losses are barely punished at all, and wins make your rating go up much faster. A common complaint about the current rating system is actually that it's too hard on stronger players since winning so much is penalized as much as...
by mturton
07 April 2024, 11:41
Forum: Discussions
Topic: Reconsider Arena Rankings System
Replies: 68
Views: 3662

Re: Reconsider Arena Rankings System

I stopped playing Arena because the current system disincentivizes play because losses are punished so heavily. The simplest thing to do is make each level a fixed number of wins, with the number increasing at each level. Losses dont hurt, but each win helps. The winner would be the one who reached...

Go to advanced search