Search found 7 matches

by Thamoo
07 October 2022, 05:37
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

As for cards that are "too strong"? IMO there are a lot of "too strong" cards (circumstantially) in Agricola. It's why we draft, right? From behind the veil of ignorance (not knowing if I'm the one opening the particular card), do I think Agricola is a better or more interesting...
by Thamoo
06 September 2022, 03:53
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

if I recall correctly whenever I got both trade teacher and an hearth the game becomes trivially easy. A card can't be a (very efficient) food engine, a way to get breeding pairs and your grain/veg source at the same time and be balanced. As it stands I would pick it above begging student. I underst...
by Thamoo
17 August 2022, 22:36
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

Agreed with Ranior's list, though I guess wood piles can stay. Other than that: - Family friendly home seems a bit too strong and way too swingy - Wood slide hammer : ridiculously strong - Lord of the mayor/cow prince : I THINK those are fine, though I admit I'm biased as I love playing a 3 room gam...
by Thamoo
10 August 2022, 21:20
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Private Teacher + Field Watchman
Replies: 3
Views: 821

Re: Private Teacher + Field Watchman

What a fun interaction haha. That said, I don't think that's the correct behavior. According to the unofficial agricola (revised) compendium, using an action space is defined as : "First placing a person, then taking at least one action provided by the action space or taking a replacement actio...
by Thamoo
19 February 2022, 08:12
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

Having played some more, I now agree with the begging student ban. That card is way too strong. Tiller I haven't seen many day labor combos since CD decks got added. When they hit though it is indeed brutal. That said I do hate draft loam pit fairly highly which may contribute to why I don't see it ...
by Thamoo
01 February 2022, 00:35
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

Personally i'm very happy with the current banlist. It seems obvious that agricola is a much better competitive game without caravan, braggart and carriage trip (I will not comment on cross-cut wood as I have never played it). I think it's dangerous to only consider power level (even though it is th...
by Thamoo
29 July 2021, 02:55
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 91763

Re: Banlist Discussion!

Agreed on both count.

Go to advanced search