Search found 43 matches

by BusterVA
09 December 2025, 01:55
Forum: Catan
Topic: Bad sportsmanship...kicking players out on winning turns
Replies: 51
Views: 2090

Re: Bad sportsmanship...kicking players out on winning turns

The issue is that there are players who know they are going to lose and kick players out that are seconds away from winning to avoid the loss. The issue is that there are players who take more time than allowed and still think they're winning. This is the answer right there. If you can't win in the...
by BusterVA
27 November 2025, 01:05
Forum: Catan
Topic: Against the stupid “gg!”
Replies: 33
Views: 1817

Re: Against the stupid “gg!”

I find it quite ugly when - especially winners - vomit a "gg" into the chat. Actually, I also find it ugly when loosers do it. It's a robotic ugliness and I don't think it is a real and honest appreciation. Just vomit. It would be easy to choose one of the prepared statements (with real w...
by BusterVA
06 November 2025, 01:13
Forum: Catan
Topic: For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player counts?
Replies: 13
Views: 338

Re: For the love of all that is holy in the heavens and on the earth, can we use the 5-6 player map for 3-4 player count

The fight over the best spaces is why I like 4 player the best. Spot on. The limited space is what makes Catan shine. It makes it necessary to trade and co-operate and it's what makes it possible to threaten and block. Playing 3 players on the standard board is basically just pick the best numbers ...
by BusterVA
03 November 2025, 23:35
Forum: Catan
Topic: Bad sportsmanship...kicking players out on winning turns
Replies: 51
Views: 2090

Re: Bad sportsmanship...kicking players out on winning turns

I have had enough of the poor sportsmanship on this site! In the last month I've been kicked out of probably a dozen games that I was clearly leading often on a final move that would win the game. I understand that this is partly my fault. There have been some poor connections and I've had to refre...
by BusterVA
03 November 2025, 23:28
Forum: Catan
Topic: Blatant cheating but you can't call it cheating ???
Replies: 20
Views: 1288

Re: Blatant cheating but you can't call it cheating ???

First of all the moderation that goes around BGA is excessive. No warnings just straight to silencing or removal of reputation I said something very similar to this once - they muted my chat for 10 days and cut my karma down to 50/100. I won't comment further as I don't want the same "punishme...
by BusterVA
29 October 2025, 22:05
Forum: Catan
Topic: Please Help Me Understand Arena Scoring...
Replies: 5
Views: 110

Re: Please Help Me Understand Arena Scoring...

Thank you everyone for the responses. I was under the impression that higher ELO players would still give more Arena points. Clearly that is just not the case. The fact that it is a separate scoring system and based entirely on Arena points makes perfect sense and clears that up for sure! Not that i...
by BusterVA
29 October 2025, 19:02
Forum: Catan
Topic: Please Help Me Understand Arena Scoring...
Replies: 5
Views: 110

Please Help Me Understand Arena Scoring...

I am super confused by the arena scoring for Catan. It just does not make sense. I played a game where I beat two players who both had higher ELO than me. (I was in the mid 100s, they were in the mid/high 200s) I expected my arena score to go up a decent amount. It went up ONE point for arena.Just o...
by BusterVA
07 October 2025, 21:47
Forum: Catan
Topic: Excessive Trade Requests
Replies: 3
Views: 108

Re: Excessive Trade Requests

I SO wish there was a mechanic in this game to just click "never accept trades" and have all trades auto-declined. I find there are a lot of people who play and ask for trades constantly, like you said, multiple times per turn. Just stop already. "I didn't have wood when you asked las...
by BusterVA
07 October 2025, 19:15
Forum: Catan
Topic: Variable setup with random numbers and friendly robber in arena is back
Replies: 21
Views: 409

Re: Variable setup with random numbers and friendly robber in arena is back

I have been in many games where I have first pick and get a spot like the one you note. I even had one not long ago, but was 8/8/6. 8s were wheat and ore, 6 was sheep. I lost that game. There were ZERO 8s rolled. Zero. And only a handful of 6's. Big numbers that game were 3's and 11's, rolled consta...
by BusterVA
07 October 2025, 18:18
Forum: Catan
Topic: Catan: Friendly Robber Backstabbing
Replies: 23
Views: 905

Re: Catan: Friendly Robber Backstabbing

That's the game. In my eyes he did nothing wrong. If a player asks to play friendly and everyone agrees, then that player robs you anyways, that is just not okay. While "technically" it is not cheating, that is terrible sportsman ship and people like that should receive penalties. If you ...

Go to advanced search