Board Game Arena

Well, I don't know for sure, but that's what the message on screen said. I wasn't guilty of any of the valid reasons for giving a red thumb which is more the point.

Yet again I come to BGA to discover the wonderful "oops, you got another red thumb" message, and discover that my karma has suddenly ended up at 30%, despite IIRC being at 97% when I was last on. What makes it all the more frustrating and annoying, is that apparently this red thumb was rec...

One country's troops are currently within the border of another country. You work out who's in the wrong there.

A new "record". 27% of the rolls were the same number (5), including multiple sequences. Person on the 5? got 10 points. The other 2 players? didn't even get past 2 vp. https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=291460865

OK, so it's a bug then.

Player A offers trade. I (player B) refuse. Player A changes his offer, it doesn't give me any option to accept, just says I've refused. I'm clearly not trying to accept player C's offer to player A for something completely different.

no one?

red thumbs are arbitrary ridiculousness that should be removed entirely from the site except for personal preference. You can be red thumbed for leaving a game, despite not leaving, red thumbed for aggressive/rude chat despite never typing anything in the chat box. I suspect you got red thumbed for ...

On the basis you've played ONE game of catan on this site and the fact you can't answer the question, I'll just ignore you from this point on I think.

that wasn't my point though was it...? What is the probability of 3 out of 4 rolls being the same?

Once I decline an offer, I never have the opportunity to accept any new offers that come up? Is this a bug?