Search found 5 matches

by Aspheric
10 July 2025, 12:12
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 92414

Re: Banlist Discussion!

Lots of good discussion on here. My opinion is to agree with Swathe on all points. I would unban Informant. The card is not annoying, it is strong but no stronger than other A-tier occs (Forest Reviewer, Lover, Childless, Pavior, Basket Carrier etc) so I'm not sure why it was this one that got singl...
by Aspheric
14 September 2022, 22:25
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 92414

Re: Banlist Discussion!

In general, I am against cards being banned, especially before they have been fully road-tested in an arena season. Ideally the decision would be made based on data which shows their strength when compensating for ELO and other factors. However, that being said, the only card I am in favour of banni...
by Aspheric
29 March 2022, 21:26
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 92414

Re: Banlist Discussion!

I am happy to join the chorus for Big Country banning as it would be good to play the next arena season without it. The card does warp the game and closes down the decision space versus a normal game. I personally would wait on Begging Student for another season. I have won with it, I have lost with...
by Aspheric
24 March 2022, 15:46
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 92414

Re: Banlist Discussion!

I’m in a tournament where I have had the opportunity to draft Big Country three games in a row. However, I was passed Big Country in two of those games. I drafted the card and won the game. But did you enjoy yourself? A fair question! The answer is yes though as there are still decisions to make ar...
by Aspheric
24 March 2022, 11:21
Forum: Agricola
Topic: Banlist Discussion!
Replies: 390
Views: 92414

Re: Banlist Discussion!

A really interesting a mature discussion going on here; super to see such a passionate group of players and developers in this community. In order to make these decisions I’d prefer to do it from data and analysis. I think what we have not quite been able to demonstrate quantitatively is to strip ou...

Go to advanced search