Search found 19 matches

by apotap
27 July 2024, 09:30
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: ELO
Replies: 7
Views: 535

Re: ELO

Any game is a passion, even a cooperative one. And there is a place for passion in real life too. The desire to completely get rid of passion is absurd and sad. From now on we will eat semolina porridge without salt and sugar. I probably won't.
by apotap
22 February 2022, 15:13
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

You are right, there is a lot of psychology in this game. Different levels of psychology.
We should sometimes concede the game to our teammates just out of politeness.
by apotap
07 February 2022, 17:00
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

Yes :) But I think it was just accumulated irritation :roll:
by apotap
07 February 2022, 12:55
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

Yesterday we had game for 3 players, I was the 1st player. The 2nd player has trash in all his 5 positions. So I skipped him and give a clue to the 3rd player. 2nd player discarded and draw 5 (which could not be played). I skipped him again. And then... he played the left 5! Why? Because "I hav...
by apotap
03 February 2022, 10:30
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

Silene wrote: 02 February 2022, 16:01 The fact that you were skipped does not add any information about your half-clued card.
It's still 50% chance only - don't play it unless you get real information (not from skipping)!
Ok, thanks. It was my opinion too, and I'm glad community think similar.
by apotap
02 February 2022, 15:19
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

Skip means you’ve got something better to do than to give the clue that was used to skip. Nothing more than that. Sure. But besides the giving clue I have TWO possibilities - play (half-clued) card or discard (unknown card). Which of them should I choose "by default"? Without additional i...
by apotap
02 February 2022, 15:13
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

At the begining of the game, it often (not every times) means you can discard... At the end, with Good Touch Principle, if you have a marked card in your hand and they may me playable, it is. J Hmm... and WHEN the begining become the end? :? Also, if a player skip you when they have a play, then it...
by apotap
01 February 2022, 19:58
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Re: Does skip means 'play' or 'discard'?

When you are skipped, it means the player sitting before you does not care much about your chop card. But it doesn't mean you HAVE to discard now. You can still make your own choice. Yes, sure. But if I was skipped, and for example have clued 4 of unknown color, and some 4s can be played now and so...
by apotap
01 February 2022, 17:42
Forum: Hanabi
Topic: Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?
Replies: 19
Views: 3275

Does skip mean 'play' or 'discard'?

I'm the 1st player. The 2nd player has one half-marked card (and doesn't know if he can play it or not). And all other cards in his hand are trash. And there is obvious clue for 3rd player, one of us should make. Should I skip and give this clue? In order to save my (unknown) cards and force 2nd to ...

Go to advanced search