Is this bug?

[PenTus]

I have found two versions of rulebooks where there is a difference in phase 11: Update and Add New Mountain Strips.
Sometimes there is one additional sentence after "remove the leftmost building resource":

If all spaces but the last "2 silver" space are empty, remove the two silver and the entire mountain strip.

The way it is implemented on BGA those 2 silver are not removed in such situation.

Should we consider it as bug and report it?

Instruction where there is such sentence (page 11):
https://boardgamegeek.com/filepage/1366 ... h-rulebook

Discussion on BGA forum:
https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/223875 ... 6#32471076

[RicardoRix]

do you have a game id or link to a game where this happens?

Are you confusing the 2 silver spots being single spots...?

[PenTus]

I have recreated it in single player game:
https://boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=344028375

Please watch the replay.

According to that additional sentence from rules there should not be a mountain strip with only 2 silver on beginning of turn 2. That 2 silver should be remove and mountain strip as well.

[RicardoRix]

https://boardgamegeek.com/filepage/1380 ... sh-edition

Rulebook, page 11
The details about the Mountain Strips should read:
• In this phase, remove the leftmost resource (i.e., closest to the
arrow) from each face-up mountain strip and return it to the
general supply (this can be wood, stone, ore or silver).
If all spaces are empty, remove the mountain strip.

[PenTus]

Ok, thanks for an answer