cheat

[dawe21]

salut tt le monde, je ne pense pas etre le premier a m'exprimer sur le sujet, mais je le fais en francais.
Je parle essentiellement de Carcassonne : Au debut, je pensais que seul l'algorithme disrribuait les bonnes et les mauvaises tuiles..Bah, n 'etant pas membre premium (je m excuse), je me suis convaincu que c etait le jeu...mais la depuis 1 mois environ, je vois des mecs posé des tuiles sans reflechir, et leur donner toutes les villes, même les plus improbable,,les prés, etc....ca me fait penser à une application pirate qui s'appelait aimbot à l epoque, ou quoi que tu faisais, il te donnait la solution pour gagner......en bref, je pense que bga est "aimboté"....

[MacDuc]

You just have to report some of these games and they look into it. =>
Il vous suffit de signaler certains de ces jeux et ils se penchent sur la question.

[nik592]

That said (and this has been discussed on the forums before), the amount of work to create a bot for the amount of gain to hold an arbitrary ranking on a website makes doing such a thing seem unlikely. If you REALLY think a player is a bot, feel free to red thumb them, and you won't see them again. If you think lots of players are bots? You're probably not seeing as many as you think.

[Meeplelowda]

That said (and this has been discussed on the forums before), the amount of work to create a bot for the amount of gain to hold an arbitrary ranking on a website makes doing such a thing seem unlikely. If you REALLY think a player is a bot, feel free to red thumb them, and you won't see them again. If you think lots of players are bots? You're probably not seeing as many as you think.

I think the OP is also discounting the fact that some Carcassonne players on BGA are freakishly good (I am not, but some of the top players post their YouTube videos explaining how they do what they do). At the top rankings they all have all of the tiles memorized and can use that knowledge to maximize the chances that what they draw will be useful. That doesn't mean they are manipulating the odds. It just means that they set things up so that many things that get drawn will help. When they place a piece, they don't just think about how it scores on this turn. They think about how many pieces are left that may convert the currently placed piece into points on later turns.

That combined with the typical confirmation bias baked into these types of accusations will lead to the perception that they have some kind of mystical powers.

[Lymon Flowers]

salut tt le monde, je ne pense pas etre le premier a m'exprimer sur le sujet, mais je le fais en francais.
Je parle essentiellement de Carcassonne : Au debut, je pensais que seul l'algorithme disrribuait les bonnes et les mauvaises tuiles..Bah, n 'etant pas membre premium (je m excuse), je me suis convaincu que c etait le jeu...mais la depuis 1 mois environ, je vois des mecs posé des tuiles sans reflechir, et leur donner toutes les villes, même les plus improbable,,les prés, etc....ca me fait penser à une application pirate qui s'appelait aimbot à l epoque, ou quoi que tu faisais, il te donnait la solution pour gagner......en bref, je pense que bga est "aimboté"....

Bonjour,
ce n'est pas possible, la distribution des tuiles est faite côté serveur. Les joueurs n'ont aucune possibilité d'agir ni même anticiper les tuiles qui seront distribuées. Contrairement à un jeu type FPS où le client sait plus d'informations qu'il ne devrait savoir et où la triche est possible!

Hello,
this is not possible, tiles distribution is done server-side. Players have no way modifiying ou even anticipating which tiles will be drawed. On the contrary with a FPS where the client software knows more than it should!


Benj

[Respublik]

That said (and this has been discussed on the forums before), the amount of work to create a bot for the amount of gain to hold an arbitrary ranking on a website makes doing such a thing seem unlikely.

Not regarding the OP's complaint, but maybe it says something about the level of enforcement on the site that this isn't the case on the BGA. They are also paying for the premium on top of the above