Page 2 of 2
Re: Renaming birds?
Posted: 10 November 2023, 11:44
by pjt33
bananasplay wrote: ↑10 November 2023, 07:55
Hmm, in what way is the game currently not consistent with respect to Cartographer?
desert, forest, island, jungle, mallee, marsh, moor, mountain, plains, prairie, sandhill, savannah, scrub, sea, wood. Which is the odd one out?
Re: Renaming birds?
Posted: 02 January 2024, 17:20
by Adasaur
pjt33 wrote: ↑10 November 2023, 11:44
bananasplay wrote: ↑10 November 2023, 07:55
Hmm, in what way is the game currently not consistent with respect to Cartographer?
desert, forest, island, jungle, mallee, marsh, moor, mountain, plains, prairie, sandhill, savannah, scrub, sea, wood. Which is the odd one out?
These all seem fine to me; they're all terms that refer to a habitat or geographic feature. I'm not sure which one you're referencing. Maybe "wood" versus "woods", though that term isn't listed on any version of my physical Cartographer cards and I don't think it's in the BGA version either.
Re: Renaming birds?
Posted: 02 January 2024, 20:24
by pjt33
Adasaur wrote: ↑02 January 2024, 17:20
pjt33 wrote: ↑10 November 2023, 11:44
bananasplay wrote: ↑10 November 2023, 07:55
Hmm, in what way is the game currently not consistent with respect to Cartographer?
desert, forest, island, jungle, mallee, marsh, moor, mountain, plains, prairie, sandhill, savannah, scrub, sea, wood. Which is the odd one out?
These all seem fine to me; they're all terms that refer to a habitat or geographic feature. I'm not sure which one you're referencing. Maybe "wood" versus "woods", though that term isn't listed on any version of my physical Cartographer cards and I don't think it's in the BGA version either.
Precisely. Wood Stork and Wood Duck don't count towards Cartographer, even though all the other habitat names do.
Re: Renaming birds?
Posted: 03 January 2024, 04:46
by Adasaur
Oh, I get it now. Perhaps because they're not referring to "woods" themselves as in the general habitat (hence my making the distinction between "wood" vs "woods") but rather like an individual tree. Otherwise something like a treecreeper or roadrunner would count for this as well.
Re: Renaming birds?
Posted: 10 July 2024, 04:14
by enbycass
paramesis wrote: ↑03 November 2023, 02:50
When the implementation first went live on BGA, I asked the publisher about an evolving list of excluded cards, and they were strongly against it. There are no plans to "ban" any cards beyond the existing game option to exclude the "power 4"
How quickly your plans changed from not banning any more birds other than the power 4 to banning the Wood Duck as well. Love being lied to.
We should probably start a pool on when the Pileated Woodpecker gets banned and then the Chipping Sparrow and California Quail after that.