Page 2 of 2

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 24 September 2013, 16:20
by pablo74
One solution could be to avoid all kinds of pronouns:
- Uwe/Lisa wirft alle eigenen Handkarten ab
- Uwe/Lisa wift alle Handkarten ab (which might be not specific enough)

Futhermore, there are a number of rewrittings that help to avoid the usage of player_name-strings (like passive).

I also agree with the ranking of yzemaze:
If male only isn't an option I'd use female only. As a last resort I wouldn't mind Option 2 as long as a commonly used form (b, d or e) is used.

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 24 September 2013, 18:01
by yzemaze
Anansi wrote: Would the form "{player_name} wirft alle ihre/seine Handkarten ab." be preferable to this in your opinion?
It would be ok, but not preferable. I don't have a problem with wrong pronouns if it's done consistently site-wide [= status quo ante]. But sometimes there's the easier way of entirely circumventing the use of (possessive) pronouns [cp. pablos remarks].

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 25 September 2013, 13:56
by Anansi
Changing to a pronoun-less notation is ok for me, so unless there are any further comments I'd start changing back to all male forms and pronoun-less player_strings.

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 25 September 2013, 14:37
by pablo74
hello Anansi,

that sounds good for me.

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 25 September 2013, 16:44
by yzemaze
pablo74 wrote:hello Anansi,

that sounds good for me.
+1

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 25 September 2013, 23:05
by boloni
Anansi wrote:Changing to a pronoun-less notation is ok for me, so unless there are any further comments I'd start changing back to all male forms and pronoun-less player_strings.
I think pronoun-less notation is a good compromise

Re: gender forms?

Posted: 29 May 2017, 11:22
by Een