Page 2 of 3

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 07:04
by LucianObi
alicebob wrote: 29 September 2025, 13:13 The more Knizia games, the better.
Yes!

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 08:34
by adrian91
nice, now i'm waiting for the Ecosystem

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 08:57
by mayar21
Good addition, more old classic games like this one please.

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 12:14
by vdzero
Glad to be able to play the game here. One thing that bugged me was the colored numbers on cards are easy to mix.

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 15:48
by jatubio
Thank you for this game!

I really don't understand the rules. On this game: https://boardgamearena.com/archive/repl ... 1;&goto=24

I could play my green 9 and sum a total of 20, but my opponent claims the rock with theirs 19. How that can be possible?

Image

Here, it's the same, I already have a sum of 14 on the board, but he wins the rock with a value of only 11.

Image

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 18:50
by Glass Jar Games
Great questions!
There's a player aid at the bottom left and it ranks the best set of 3 cards. Your opponent won those stones because they have a color set and that beats a sum alone

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 20:45
by Meeplelowda
Glass Jar Games wrote: 30 September 2025, 18:50 Great questions!
There's a player aid at the bottom left and it ranks the best set of 3 cards. Your opponent won those stones because they have a color set and that beats a sum alone
Yeah. It would be a completely different game strategically if only the sum mattered.

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 30 September 2025, 21:27
by jatubio
Thank you for your answers. I thought color set were only "consecutive cards", like 123, 456 or 567. Not 147 or 269.

Anyway, I had another game with the opposite situation and I didn't win the rock either. I created a post on the game forum for better discussion: https://boardgamearena.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=45147

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 01 October 2025, 02:25
by phonetician
Finally 🎉

Re: SCHOTTEN TOTTEN: kill or be kilt

Posted: 01 October 2025, 03:18
by Saisha R
Strummerville wrote: 29 September 2025, 13:37 A classic.
Disappointing to see that there's no tutorial at launch though. You've done great work to ensure that most launch titles have a tutorial, I hope that continues.
If you're interested in Video-style Tutorial, I have made one for Schotten Totten(BGA specific) so that you can start playing right away. Here's the link https://youtu.be/80AyFTpqYdQ