Board Game Arena

DVC wrote: ↑16 July 2026, 02:30

Satori Sanada wrote: ↑15 July 2026, 19:28 NO ONE APPRECIATES WHAT CATAN IS. U have been asked for 2 SEASONS to turn off friendly robber for multiple reasons. 1 NO ONE TRADES, 2 people will delay getting to 4+ points for as long as possible, 3- IT ENCOURAGES TEAMING, 4 It punishes people who actually position good & can do things like longest road with 1/2 extra settlements make total of 6/7 points. 4- 3 player rank isn't the same as for tournaments. Also, people have been asking for the expansion because it fixes some issues like u can use a knight to STOP a player from expanding where u want to go or denying the longest road. I've had MANY 3-player games I feel as I was teamed on for putting a settlement early &/or a city. Also, were a player or both did placement to deny an area to me or to rush settlement, so I am perma stuck in that 1 area. If u WON'T add the expansion, at least turn OFF friendly robber & easy start. Also, do a swap between 3/4 players so BOTH sides are happy. THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE!!!!!!

The so-called Catan "gurus" don't have a clue how the game works on a competitive level. It's been stuck at 3p for EVERY season since the game went live 4 years ago. Every official IRL tournament uses 4p games because it is better balanced and requires more skill to win. Also Friendly Robber is not used because, well, that's for new players and family games. Easy Start is sometimes used, but very rarely. Number chits are either "curated" with pre-balanced boards, or the spiral setup is used ("variable" on BGA, NOT "variable with random numbers"). I have complained every season in the forum threads for improvements but as I've never been a guru, I can't vote for change. Yes, Cities and Knights would be a dream, but it would be nice just to have 4p, even for one season. As it stands, for 4 years straight, the Arena setup has been a joke. I've boycotted it, along with many serious players.

Satori Sanada wrote: ↑18 July 2026, 21:16 Where do u play online?

Waikirikiri wrote: ↑20 July 2026, 00:42 Memoir 44 is broken.

Arena games will not start

Please fix it

Jeronimon wrote: ↑16 July 2026, 03:59 Vote for the bug here: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=232182

miklomike wrote: ↑16 July 2026, 03:36 Haha, thanks! I knew there were a few following my journey. Always like when others update for anyone following along, or even in the future for reference. At least someone finally reached out instead of just ignoring it for the last 7 seasons.

Jeronimon wrote: ↑20 July 2026, 08:53

Waikirikiri wrote: ↑20 July 2026, 00:42 Memoir 44 is broken.

Arena games will not start

Please fix it

Indeed

Did you see this

Jeronimon wrote: ↑16 July 2026, 03:59 Vote for the bug here: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=232182

Meeplelowda wrote: ↑19 July 2026, 02:00

Satori Sanada wrote: ↑18 July 2026, 21:16 Where do u play online?

Promoting (even merely naming) other online board game platforms is prohibited on BGA, even platforms that are not meaningfully a competitor to BGA, like the two large chess platforms out there.