The best iteration of Forest Shuffle. Prettiest cards, cutest animals, and most of all the most balanced in terms of scoring variation AND gameplay through card bonuses. The archetypes are all worth to go for and they compliment each other nicely so you can have a plan B depending on which cards of the archetype you get most. If you have mice with a few owls or fish with a few eagles you might consider the 30 points for 5 birds and put some birds to reach it that let you control your hand like the 0 cost that let you pick up a card, if you're doing insects and you get two fishes multiplicators, why not go for the bear and maybe the eagle if you get fishes that accelerates the game for you like the one with grass. It's not one-dimensional and it makes the luck factor a bit less frustrating than the previous FS.
About draw, I feel like all the card bonuses and ways of manipulating your hand and the clearing make it so cards that makes you draw aren't as much of a game changer as the previous Forest Shuffle especially the first one. They are more like a bonus and are costly enough for it to be a bit questionable to play them or not instead of it being a no brainer must-pick-and-play.
I feel like putting trees down and the management of trees feel hard sometimes, I often found myself lacking tree space and I usually put more trees than average player in FS games. Sometimes I struggle to find a tree at all and I agree with what have been said with this issue early game which feels frustrating. It is very rare that I put down a tree species that feels like I can do something with it at the moment I put it and its more of a no-choice thing.
Like all other Forest Shuffle games, it is a completely different game in terms of balancing when you play with 5 players or 2 players, and the 5 players is always the worst option with terrible balancing. I wish they found a way to make that a better experience since its the 3rd game they make with the same issue. There's simply not enough cards to play before the last winter AND this Forest Shuffle iteration is the worst of all 5 players gameplay because of so many cards that accelerates the draw pile and deny cards from the clearing for other players. I dont think its that much an issue in BGA where most ppl play as 2 or 3 but I play this game IRL a lot too and it feels frustrating. In the 5 players configuration the 30 points cards are just bonkers and there's gonna be 3 players out of 5 that don't draw any or any they could play through the game. Just play this game with 2 or 3 players !
But yeah I like it the most. To improve (maybe in later expansions?) :
- Trees feeling better to play (yes)
- More rivers that do something
- Caves that do something, even if it can be unbalanced, it really added something in dartmoor. In this iteration, we have very nice cards from different archetypes that interact with cave and I feel cave could be exploited a little bit more. I don't think there should be more cards that do cave things because the game needs to have the only interaction between players that can happen with the clearing and I think there already enough denying possibilities with the card bonuses. But improving scoring with cave, whether straight up or with specific actions could be really nice. I always thought it would be an awesome thing if in the original Forest Shuffle you'd get additional points if you put bats in your cave. Card draw with cave would be a good thing in this iteration.
Special mention to the work put into the online adaptation it is pretty more readable and the symbol count is a gift. I hope they can update the other ones with this layout!
About draw, I feel like all the card bonuses and ways of manipulating your hand and the clearing make it so cards that makes you draw aren't as much of a game changer as the previous Forest Shuffle especially the first one. They are more like a bonus and are costly enough for it to be a bit questionable to play them or not instead of it being a no brainer must-pick-and-play.
I feel like putting trees down and the management of trees feel hard sometimes, I often found myself lacking tree space and I usually put more trees than average player in FS games. Sometimes I struggle to find a tree at all and I agree with what have been said with this issue early game which feels frustrating. It is very rare that I put down a tree species that feels like I can do something with it at the moment I put it and its more of a no-choice thing.
Like all other Forest Shuffle games, it is a completely different game in terms of balancing when you play with 5 players or 2 players, and the 5 players is always the worst option with terrible balancing. I wish they found a way to make that a better experience since its the 3rd game they make with the same issue. There's simply not enough cards to play before the last winter AND this Forest Shuffle iteration is the worst of all 5 players gameplay because of so many cards that accelerates the draw pile and deny cards from the clearing for other players. I dont think its that much an issue in BGA where most ppl play as 2 or 3 but I play this game IRL a lot too and it feels frustrating. In the 5 players configuration the 30 points cards are just bonkers and there's gonna be 3 players out of 5 that don't draw any or any they could play through the game. Just play this game with 2 or 3 players !
But yeah I like it the most. To improve (maybe in later expansions?) :
- Trees feeling better to play (yes)
- More rivers that do something
- Caves that do something, even if it can be unbalanced, it really added something in dartmoor. In this iteration, we have very nice cards from different archetypes that interact with cave and I feel cave could be exploited a little bit more. I don't think there should be more cards that do cave things because the game needs to have the only interaction between players that can happen with the clearing and I think there already enough denying possibilities with the card bonuses. But improving scoring with cave, whether straight up or with specific actions could be really nice. I always thought it would be an awesome thing if in the original Forest Shuffle you'd get additional points if you put bats in your cave. Card draw with cave would be a good thing in this iteration.
Special mention to the work put into the online adaptation it is pretty more readable and the symbol count is a gift. I hope they can update the other ones with this layout!