Page 3 of 6

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 29 July 2021, 16:37
by perfectvelvet
I also find the trading round to be confusing. The option "done trading" makes me think I'm submitting my trade offers, not ending trading all together. May I suggest something like "end trade round" or "stop trading this round" or something a little less confusing? "Wait" could be changed to "wait for offers" or something similar.

I'd also like a way to offer an either/or trade that doesn't require me to repost the same trade several times. For instance, I will give my red bean for either a blue or green bean. Is there a way to input a button like that?

This can't be an easy game to translate, so I'm honestly impressed by how well it works so far! After you figure out what you're doing, it plays just like the real thing. Bravo to you.

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 01 September 2021, 13:25
by cikson
Can someone include me in Bohnanza players group? I would like to play Bohnanza. I'm member of BGA reviewers group.
THX!

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 09 September 2021, 17:32
by PappyGarcia
I would like to be added as well please.

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 09 September 2021, 21:11
by CmdrOverbite
Would love to help push this over the top as well!

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 28 September 2021, 14:10
by Steve camlot
Could u add me to test the game ? Please !! Thank u =P

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 12 November 2021, 16:57
by yvonne-vino
Love this game!
Is it still in alpha?

I would like to test it :D

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 15 November 2021, 18:16
by fraleel
If it helps here are the scenarios that were thought of for trading (where AP = active player/trader, and NAP = non-active player)

- ap post offer
- nap post offer
- ap/nap cancel own offer
- nap try to match ap offer
- nap try to match other nap offer
- ap decline nap offer
- ap match/accept nap offer
- ap counter nap offer
- wait for other offers as ap
- wait for other offers as nap
- wake up others
- done trading as nap
- done trading ap
The biggest issue with the trading and asynchronous play is that people can post offers that can never be resolved and there's only the chat window to explain why.

It would help if there was a mechanism for each player to indicate, essentially, " Here's what I have to work with " that *isn't* a trade. That would help move the game along, I think

It's the difference between "rejecting" an offer and "can't fufill" an offer.

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 19 March 2022, 16:30
by TomKy
Has this stopped or halted? I Really like this game. Its also hard to get a game going.

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 15 April 2022, 04:46
by towehaal
My guess is it has been abandoned--if you look at the bugs page there have been no updates in over half a year or moe.

Re: Bohnanza

Posted: 04 January 2024, 19:53
by susuqie
I want to play this game toooooo
Will it ever make it out of Alpha??