Page 3 of 7

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 09 January 2022, 16:57
by u-topia
I've also added a tutorial on Nautilus.

I have also added tutorials by both villager and nccc, who have created many tutorials.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 09 January 2022, 17:10
by u-topia
The link to the Alpha version tutorial is in the very first post.
Please play and rate it, everyone.
Thank you very much.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 09 January 2022, 17:27
by u-topia
nccc wrote: 09 January 2022, 03:39 For this tutorail, if u want to protect ur 3, u can also place stone in these places.
https://snipboard.io/n1zI07.jpg
If you place them in the three places in the image, they will be taken by your opponent.
I think there is only one place where you can prevent them from taking it on the next turn.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 09 January 2022, 22:08
by Clutron

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 11 January 2022, 16:35
by u-topia
cigma wrote: 06 January 2022, 21:20 Hello u-topia, I have just checked your tutorial on YOKAI
hello cigma.
Sorry for the delay in replying.
I've been busy with other work, so it took me a while to check the forum.

Thanks for the great suggestions.
I created this tutorial quite a while ago, so I'll be reviewing it myself and incorporating your input.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 12 January 2022, 23:38
by u-topia
Add Icebreaker

Removed the list of games that have been promoted to beta.
Thank you to those who tested it.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 13 January 2022, 14:16
by Clutron
Thanks for the people that helped, Mother Road has been promoted to beta!

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 14 January 2022, 13:26
by u-topia
I've upgraded Youkai on cigma's advice.
Thank you very much for your valuable opinion.

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 14 January 2022, 20:52
by cigma
Hello u-topia,
this time I have checked your tutorial on CONCEPT
https://boardgamearena.com/tutorial?gam ... torial=348

I found some things which seem obvious if you know the game, but might be not if you are new to it:

In your first example (crow) you ask: „What comes to your mind if you see these 3 symbols?“
It could perhaps be more helpful if you ask: „What comes to your mind if you combine these 3 symbols (animal, flying, black)?“
(as you do later to describe the helicopter… You might also refer to the tooltips here.)

When you explain the "main concept pawn", it could be useful to mention that it has the shape of a question mark.

You give some good examples to get familiar with the concept of Concept ;-)

I like very much that you emphasize the difference between main and sub concepts. This is crucial!

At one point you explain how to "give up". I think it is important to make clear this is not meant like "giving up" in any other game on BGA (which you can choose by the three horizontal lines (= hamburger menu) on the top right), but the "give up" button in the title bar.

I had some issues with the position of things on the screen:
- "Enter your guess" - not in the right position, it points to the package on my screen. Maybe better use a coloured frame (in addition) for this and the following?
- "If you want to remove the pawn/cube, click on the trash symbol." - You could add here: "This is found at the right side" - frame?
- "Click foot symbol" (on my screen it points to the zero) - frame?
- "Guesses on the left" - frame?
(- But the position is good for "sports" on my screen - frame?)

Thank you again for one of your valuable tutorials! I am sure people will apreciate it :-D

Re: Please evaluate the tutorial of the game that you know, and please cooperate with improvement of BGA

Posted: 14 January 2022, 20:56
by cigma
Edit: Deleted because of duplicate entry