Page 3 of 6
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 07 February 2023, 17:35
by Winn81
Can you make it a poll? I think would be much clearer than forum responses.
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 07 February 2023, 18:41
by MagnusNygaard
Winn81 wrote: ↑07 February 2023, 17:35
Can you make it a poll? I think would be much clearer than forum responses.
I don't know how to make a poll here... Is there a way?
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 03:32
by Winn81
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 04:10
by Waikirikiri
This poll would, imho, be better if it allowed votes for which should be removed and which should be retained.
As it stands this is a very negative poll designed to produce a very skewed, biased, result.
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 04:15
by Reaper76
Works great thank you for taking the time to make this constructive
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 04:49
by Winn81
Waikirikiri,
It's not designed to produce a skewed result. In fact, I'm only in favor of removing Sidi Rezegh Airfield and 1st Armored to the rescue, the two most unbalanced scenarios which require center cards or you can't win.
I added another option: "None". Sorry for the oversight.
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 06:12
by Waikirikiri
Winn81 wrote: ↑10 February 2023, 04:49
Waikirikiri,
It's not designed to produce a skewed result. In fact, I'm only in favor of removing Sidi Rezegh Airfield and 1st Armored to the rescue, the two most unbalanced scenarios which require center cards or you can't win.
I added another option: "None". Sorry for the oversight.
It may not be designed to produce a skewed result but that is what it will produce.
Any reputable pollster would never use a poll like this.
If you think your poll is okay, then turn it around, have people vote for the scenarios that should be kept.
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 06:35
by ripted pizzaz
Winn81 wrote: ↑10 February 2023, 04:49
In fact, I'm only in favor of removing Sidi Rezegh Airfield and 1st Armored to the rescue.
I agree. If any were to be removed, it should be these two. But I'd also vote for none.
Individual games don't really matter, it's performance over time that determines ELO and Arena points and over time the imbalances even out.
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 10:50
by M44 fan
Why such a long list?
UNBELIEVABLE!
Re: Adding or removing scenarios from ARENA
Posted: 10 February 2023, 11:49
by jeroenh
Wow, amazing the diversity of opinions. I am truly surprised by that.