Page 1 of 1

ELO for random games

Posted: 03 May 2016, 00:09
by Radek0
ELO not work well for games with random factor for example coloretto. This game is a bit random. Better player wins often but not always, even with weak opposition. Record with 50% wins for 3, 4, 5 players is good but ELO can be <1500. But with the same statistics you can have ELO >1700. In this type of games ELO should consider statistics not only ELO = ELO + new result

Re: ELO for random games

Posted: 03 May 2016, 01:00
by Oso
Radek0 wrote:ELO not work well for games with random factor for example coloretto. This game is a bit random. Better player wins often but not always, even with weak opposition. Record with 50% wins for 3, 4, 5 players is good but ELO can be <1500. But with the same statistics you can have ELO >1700. In this type of games ELO should consider statistics not only ELO = ELO + new result
ELO works in ALL GAMES.

So, luck games are most difficult to get a higher rating. Get 1800 in Can't Stop is similar than 2000 in Chess or Checkers.

Just in my opinion, I enjoy more "luck" games before "only strategy",,,

Re: ELO for random games

Posted: 10 May 2016, 11:45
by fedetsrm
Yes agreed with OSO, i played both games lucky based and non, but ELO works in both types of games!

Re: ELO for random games

Posted: 16 May 2016, 02:33
by LaviSorrow
So if 2000 elo in Chess is like 1800 in Can't stop maybe luck based games should have lower requirements for Master badge ;)

Re: ELO for random games

Posted: 20 May 2016, 06:54
by Liallan
You need to take the games within the context of what they are. Or maybe you should consider that it's extremely difficult to become a "master" of Can't Stop when a newbie can beat you through luck. A true master would figure out how to beat them. :D