Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/#!bugs
User avatar
hanavesigoblin
Posts: 1
Joined: 08 April 2018, 22:04

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby hanavesigoblin » 14 September 2018, 16:36

sapphire778 wrote:An alternative to consider is configuring the game such that there is a higher probability of getting 3-saboteur rounds in a regular 7-player game. Currently, this probability seems to stand at around...60%.

This would be a good compromise if the programmers don't wish to include the "max sab" toggle feature, but instead retain the ambiguity and suspense elements true to the essence of this game.


I was about to suggest this too. 20-30% probability of minimum saboteurs would be good. With option to use or not to use tweaked probability, of course.
Last edited by hanavesigoblin on 14 September 2018, 18:38, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
N_Faker
Posts: 393
Joined: 09 September 2016, 10:16

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby N_Faker » 14 September 2018, 17:54

"7 players: 3 saboteurs and 5 gold-diggers"

So 3/8(37,5%) chance of being 2 sab and 5 digger, 5/8(62,5%) chance of being 3 sab and 4 digger.

uuganaa
Posts: 1
Joined: 19 April 2017, 07:56

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby uuganaa » 15 September 2018, 00:09

would love to vote on this option

User avatar
Wreckage
Posts: 8
Joined: 18 January 2017, 02:10

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby Wreckage » 15 September 2018, 02:26

The more gold for 2 sabs against 5 diggers requires a way to make that happen at all player counts. An idea to implement this could be an additional 2 gold for saboteurs if saboteur is the role card not selected.

I think the best max sab implementation might be to have the same amount of role cards as players for 2 of the 3 rounds (or 1 of the 3 rounds), and the extra role card for the other round. But the round(s) with an extra card would be randomly selected. This way the percentage of rounds with only 2 sabs would be fewer.

If there were 3 sabs in the first round there would be no way to deduce whether that was a round with an extra role card or not. I hope I wrote this idea clear enough to understand.

User avatar
Jesdebel
Posts: 2
Joined: 03 July 2018, 16:42

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby Jesdebel » 15 September 2018, 04:41

BGA, cumulatively, you’ve had players whose experience is 7,500 that are requesting max sab option. If you add in the comments regarding additional gold, you have a culmination of 10,000 + games. Clearly the 2 sab option is not working as there are suggested fixes in both camps.

User avatar
VitoDon
Posts: 1
Joined: 04 August 2017, 12:46

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby VitoDon » 15 September 2018, 11:54

2 sabs are fine!
So long faith is sab :D:D:D:D:D:D:D

User avatar
CricketVT
Posts: 3
Joined: 04 August 2017, 12:46

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby CricketVT » 15 September 2018, 18:08

For those that think 2 sabs is fine: Wreckage's original suggestion doesn't take away your ability to have games that randomize 2/3 sabs. It just gives the many of us who want to have max sabs the option to select it. The same way table creators can choose visible gold or not.

User avatar
Headhunterz
Posts: 1
Joined: 17 December 2016, 22:17

Max Sab Button and additional gold for 2v5

Postby Headhunterz » 15 September 2018, 22:29

Having a option to choose max Sabs seems to be really nice. Would appreciate that.
But i also think that there needs to be a change when you decide to play without max Sab. So the suggestion to get additonal gold in a 2v5 seems quite good.

chonti
Posts: 1
Joined: 16 June 2016, 18:16

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby chonti » 16 September 2018, 01:47

I agree. In the end it would be just an option, if players dont want it they can ignore it.

User avatar
lhexago
Posts: 6
Joined: 07 March 2018, 14:59

Re: Max Sabs option for Saboteur

Postby lhexago » 16 September 2018, 18:21

i do not like (very very much) that solution, even if i understand why the question is asked.

having 2 or 3 sabs (in 7 players game) and find them is a part of the game. but having 2vs5 all the time is boring and much more if you are one of these sabs.

i would prefer that :
- diggers earn less when 2vs5 is won by diggers. all would have just one card 'gold' or they could win 1 gold by cad only (maybe too complicate)
- or there can be just one 2vs5 during the whole game.
- or just change the probability to have 2vs5.

-giving more options to sabs in a 2vs5 game would be nice but changes totally the "spirit" of the game.

but at least, i would not be upset if that solution would be implemented :P

:)


Return to “Saboteur”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests