Page 1 of 8
Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 07 June 2021, 18:35
by atcblake
I’m currently testing the alpha version of GWT and so far it has been very smooth. My one piece of feedback thus far though is to not show the total points each player has. One of the things I enjoy about GWT is that you might have an idea of how many points players have based on what they do during the game, but there’s no point tracker in the physical version which shows you exactly where they stand. I feel like for less experienced gamers seeing JUST how far behind they are can be very discouraging.
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 07 June 2021, 21:11
by dennislaumen
Where do I sign up for testing GWT?

Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 07 June 2021, 21:28
by Stavr0s
What what whaaaaat. GWT?? Gimme gimme (an invite)!

Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 07 June 2021, 23:17
by Barbarossa41
Where, where, where?

Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 02:32
by lucygeorges
atcblake wrote: ↑07 June 2021, 18:35
I’m currently testing the alpha version of GWT and so far it has been very smooth. My one piece of feedback thus far though is to not show the total points each player has. One of the things I enjoy about GWT is that you might have an idea of how many points players have based on what they do during the game, but there’s no point tracker in the physical version which shows you exactly where they stand. I feel like for less experienced gamers seeing JUST how far behind they are can be very discouraging.
Both points of view are understandable. I suppose better players are likely to be more competitive, but newer ones might find it useful to see how certain moves affect the score. Some games bring enormous surprises (good and bad) when the scores are totted up at the end. Could it be an option of some sort in the settings?
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 05:47
by mooken
Having played Beyond the Sun both online and physical, I appreciate knowing how well I'm doing throughout the game. I don't think it's particularly demoralizing, and it's not as if beginner players will have an expectation of keeping pace with an expert player.
In my physical games of GWT, sometimes the winner is surprising. Will showing the score during the game cause some additional AP and trying to maximize every turn? Probably -- and maybe that will encourage players to play more competitively.
Could this be an optional feature?
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 10:45
by tuananhtd
Please give me an invite for beta testing this game

(
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 14:47
by lvlc
I would be happy to help testing the implementation.
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 15:15
by eyebooger
atcblake wrote: ↑07 June 2021, 18:35
the alpha version of GWT
Wait, what?
Re: Great Western Trail - Points
Posted: 08 June 2021, 15:41
by bobasa_
I'd love to test this game out!