April 2022-September 2022: https://boardgamearena.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=28051
December 2022-July 2023: https://boardgamearena.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=31498
We are lucky to have a publisher who cares about statistics, and to have game developers Tisaac and Vincentt who have found ways to track game data (and card use!) while minimizing the impact on BGA's servers.
For full transparency: Data parsing, cleaning, and analysis is currently done by me. I am not paid by Lookout Games or BGA, and have no special contracts or formal agreements with them. I am doing this on a volunteer basis in order to improve knowledge of the game and the playing experience. All of the data is anonymized on a table and player level by using hashed table IDs and hashed player IDs. I have made zero effort to un-hash IDs, or match hashed IDs to tables or players based on other data, and I will not make any such efforts in the future. Data consists of the game settings, all statistics on the "final results" page of a game, the draft results, and when cards were played (notably: move-by-move data not included.) Card tracking was implemented approximately on November 25 and the data I have analyzed is approximately Nov 25 - Dec 10. BGA Admins are the only people who have the ability to download game data in its entirety. Game developers have access to a very limited (by recency) set of data. The data are only accessible through a BGA admin or game developer; DO NOT pester them for data, discuss here about data accessibility instead if you think it's an issue. Tell me if I need to add other things to this transparency section to match other data analysis disclaimers.
I do feel awkward (for lack of a better term) about having special access, and will try my best to share all analysis that I do. Moving forward, I will try to answer popular questions that the community wants to investigate in the data. At the bottom of this post are the analyses that I've done to this point.
How can/should the data be used?
Primarily, I have seen Agricola data be used to try to better balance the game. The most frequent discussions around balance are usually about turn order and overpowered cards.
It's relatively clear when there are imbalances in seat order, and I have tables below to show that 4th seat is particularly disadvantaged in 4-player games.
Deciding whether or not cards are overpowered is a very complex discussion. For a one-stat-fits-all approach, PWR (details here) is likely the best choice.
However, other factors can definitely be included such as ADP (Average Draft Position), Elo ratings of players and the table overall, and which game options are chosen out of the wide variety of existing settings. Based on precedent, 1st-pick cards that we can reasonably assume have a true PWR over 5.5, is a good baseline for which cards to ban. But... taking the entire set of all games and analyzing it probably isn't the best way to show the real strength of a card. As shown in PWR calculations below, what appears bannable can certainly vary depending on which subsets of the data are used.
Analysis so far (focused on 4p games, I plan to analyze the other player counts similarly)
Note: Passing cards are only tracked for the player who drafted them.
Average starting Elo and end results for all Arena games (n=855), by starting player order:
Code: Select all
order_start elo_start score end_1st end_2nd end_3rd end_4th
1 273.176620 41.498246 0.269006 0.272515 0.256140 0.202339
2 267.979825 41.113450 0.267836 0.252632 0.236257 0.243275
3 270.539754 40.877193 0.287719 0.233918 0.254971 0.223392
4 256.080608 38.784795 0.177778 0.249123 0.249123 0.323977
Code: Select all
order_start elo_start score end_1st end_2nd end_3rd end_4th
1 175.710166 37.712248 0.267044 0.259035 0.239500 0.234421
2 175.281053 37.559680 0.257081 0.247705 0.252979 0.242235
3 175.397759 37.283258 0.257668 0.244188 0.249072 0.249072
4 174.913727 36.657355 0.224263 0.248877 0.258644 0.268216
PWR Calculations for all Arena games with card tracking. APR = Average Played Round of a card.
Code: Select all
Card Name PWR ADP APR Deals Drafted Plays Win-Hand Win-Play
Big Country 5.09 1.54 8.32 331 331 263 132 118
Assistant Tiller 4.43 1.28 3.37 319 319 297 105 99
Childless 4.42 2.16 3.48 330 330 258 123 102
Grocer 4.36 2.03 9.13 308 308 261 102 94
Carpenter's Parlor 4.04 1.23 4.13 336 336 320 100 95
Mining Hammer 3.98 2.97 6.65 327 327 272 107 91
Beanfield 3.79 3.80 10.18 328 328 256 108 87
Loam Pit 3.62 1.99 8.13 335 335 252 106 85
Sleeping Corner 3.54 1.90 10.90 331 331 219 113 82
Rammed Clay 3.51 1.64 4.51 330 330 321 84 81
Moldboard Plow 3.46 2.02 7.51 322 322 290 89 78
Loom 3.42 2.20 9.82 313 313 260 89 75
House Steward 3.38 3.29 4.38 347 347 240 111 82
Mini Pasture 3.34 3.02 6.89 321 321 276 93 75
Shepherd's Crook 3.23 3.80 7.82 323 323 266 87 73
Small-scale Farmer 3.17 2.86 1.33 333 333 265 97 74
Strawberry Patch 3.17 3.48 12.79 342 342 178 115 76
Manger 3.16 4.03 11.61 326 326 201 97 72
Harpooner 3.05 2.25 3.94 323 323 268 84 69
Lumber Mill 2.99 3.52 6.67 334 334 246 91 70
Milk Jug 2.96 3.23 9.46 319 319 270 75 66
Butter Churn 2.94 3.13 7.99 340 340 288 81 70
Claypipe 2.92 5.07 8.31 323 323 192 98 66
Scholar 2.76 3.27 8.41 331 331 168 104 64
Seasonal Worker 2.73 2.22 4.33 319 319 227 88 61
Plow Driver 2.66 3.13 9.99 338 338 208 86 63
Storehouse Keeper 2.64 3.35 2.76 330 330 182 105 61
Priest 2.59 4.12 7.16 331 331 185 107 60
Threshing Board 2.55 4.43 10.71 319 319 191 88 57
Brushwood Collector 2.51 2.15 3.84 324 324 245 73 57
Pond Hut 2.48 3.77 6.92 311 311 205 82 54
Animal Tamer 2.46 4.07 8.88 308 308 197 79 53
Cottager 2.40 2.30 3.80 322 322 209 86 54
Roof Ballaster 2.38 3.86 11.99 324 324 147 115 54
Thick Forest 2.38 4.71 6.65 324 324 173 79 54
Manservant 2.29 3.96 8.72 312 312 148 95 50
Clay Hut Builder 2.26 3.76 7.08 335 335 190 87 53
Handplow 2.25 3.50 5.44 318 318 233 72 50
Bottles 2.17 3.22 10.52 329 329 197 82 50
Pastor 2.17 4.79 7.82 335 335 141 98 51
Master Bricklayer 2.16 4.45 9.28 324 324 130 93 49
Three-Field Rotation 2.16 4.63 10.56 337 337 195 86 51
Sack Cart 2.11 5.08 7.19 331 331 179 77 49
Bread Paddle 2.05 5.02 8.27 341 341 215 82 49
Mantlepiece 2.04 3.40 7.02 336 336 166 95 48
Canoe 2.01 3.02 5.61 334 334 251 66 47
Sheep Walker 2.00 3.40 10.89 321 321 164 92 45
Shifting Cultivation 1.94 4.61 8.90 338 338 240 77 46
Firewood Collector 1.89 4.12 4.11 355 355 178 86 47
Wood Cutter 1.88 2.44 2.04 334 334 280 58 44
Junk Room 1.84 4.71 5.79 334 334 222 69 43
Clearing Spade 1.84 4.92 9.22 326 326 163 77 42
Adoptive Parents 1.82 3.95 8.44 330 330 185 79 42
Organic Farmer 1.82 5.07 13.70 337 337 111 105 43
Conservator 1.79 3.05 9.42 312 312 198 63 39
Stonecutter 1.79 3.53 5.57 336 336 182 77 42
Herring Pot 1.79 4.24 6.48 319 319 187 69 40
Hard Porcelain 1.78 4.23 8.96 346 346 211 73 43
Carpenter 1.77 2.84 4.26 331 331 222 69 41
Consultant 1.69 4.70 12.51 347 347 119 105 41
Clay Embankment 1.58 5.41 9.70 343 343 152 87 38
Tutor 1.49 5.23 2.97 346 346 158 82 36
Lasso 1.48 4.45 9.43 329 329 166 74 34
Drinking Trough 1.48 5.09 9.88 329 329 163 66 34
Market Stall 1.46 5.95 10.65 332 332 148 78 34
Young Animal Market 1.45 5.70 11.37 355 355 164 87 36
Groom 1.44 5.02 10.58 348 348 106 90 35
Corn Scoop 1.41 3.96 7.06 344 344 246 60 34
Conjurer 1.40 3.99 3.81 347 347 166 86 34
Scullery 1.39 3.94 4.10 329 329 186 67 32
Acorns Basket 1.39 4.67 11.01 339 339 143 86 33
Greengrocer 1.38 3.73 7.52 342 342 216 58 33
Scythe Worker 1.30 4.75 9.24 329 329 133 74 30
Pitchfork 1.29 4.59 7.17 333 333 214 61 30
Hedge Keeper 1.16 3.56 7.33 321 321 181 59 26
Brook 1.13 4.57 5.58 341 341 149 59 27
Animal Dealer 1.12 3.90 10.21 331 331 135 65 26
Pig Breeder 1.11 5.38 12.42 335 335 99 93 26
Large Greenhouse 0.94 4.97 6.41 333 333 128 59 22
Dutch Windmill 0.91 5.66 11.59 331 331 79 70 21
Wool Blankets 0.91 6.05 12.60 328 328 68 86 21
Sheep Whisperer 0.90 5.14 3.95 317 317 96 57 20
Stone Tongs 0.86 4.72 8.43 332 332 180 51 20
Basket 0.82 6.10 8.06 330 330 90 72 19
Geologist 0.78 4.46 2.62 348 348 159 53 19
Lutenist 0.78 5.27 4.66 330 330 116 68 18
Frame Builder 0.73 4.48 7.70 332 332 128 52 17
Mushroom Collector 0.61 5.08 3.26 350 350 106 74 15
Oven Firing Boy 0.59 5.95 10.95 314 314 40 85 13
Cattle Feeder 0.52 4.85 9.38 332 332 120 50 12
Stable Architect 0.48 6.00 13.52 356 356 67 71 12
Paper Maker 0.45 5.83 5.91 321 321 74 77 10
Roughcaster 0.39 6.44 7.48 331 331 42 74 9
Wall Builder 0.26 6.13 5.55 326 326 56 62 6
Code: Select all
Card Name PWR ADP APR Deals Drafted Plays Win-Hand Win-Play
Assistant Tiller 6.44 1.23 2.78 71 71 69 34 32
Big Country 5.10 1.33 8.15 70 70 61 27 25
Carpenter's Parlor 4.56 1.15 3.93 72 72 71 23 23
Pond Hut 3.94 3.09 6.66 58 58 41 21 16
Childless 3.93 1.86 3.17 80 80 64 27 22
Sleeping Corner 3.90 1.76 10.93 66 66 44 22 18
Grocer 3.90 1.89 9.09 66 66 58 19 18
Mining Hammer 3.76 2.70 7.09 76 76 68 23 20
Seasonal Worker 3.68 2.38 4.26 66 66 50 19 17
Rammed Clay 3.67 1.66 4.56 74 74 70 20 19
Shepherd's Crook 3.67 3.53 7.95 70 70 59 20 18
Small-scale Farmer 3.52 2.75 1.31 69 69 54 24 17
Lumber Mill 3.52 2.93 6.84 73 73 56 19 18
Loam Pit 3.42 1.80 8.17 71 71 53 23 17
Beanfield 3.35 3.43 10.34 81 81 65 26 19
Priest 3.33 3.67 6.69 73 73 45 22 17
Sack Cart 3.25 4.97 7.92 79 79 49 25 18
Brushwood Collector 3.20 2.10 3.46 67 67 50 19 15
Manger 3.13 3.77 11.16 73 73 50 20 16
House Steward 3.09 3.19 3.58 74 74 53 21 16
Milk Jug 3.06 3.59 9.33 70 70 60 16 15
Strawberry Patch 3.01 3.28 12.78 76 76 40 28 16
Thick Forest 2.96 4.70 6.81 82 82 47 24 17
Mini Pasture 2.90 2.92 7.60 64 64 57 16 13
Clay Embankment 2.71 5.24 9.43 79 79 40 26 15
Threshing Board 2.68 4.22 10.89 64 64 37 20 12
Roof Ballaster 2.64 3.89 11.70 65 65 33 17 12
Pastor 2.60 4.65 7.44 77 77 36 27 14
Clay Hut Builder 2.48 3.59 6.76 69 69 41 17 12
Hard Porcelain 2.48 4.17 8.91 75 75 45 18 13
Canoe 2.45 3.39 5.69 70 70 58 14 12
Three-Field Rotation 2.44 4.74 10.70 76 76 46 22 13
Cottager 2.38 2.06 3.14 72 72 50 16 12
Master Bricklayer 2.38 4.22 8.97 72 72 33 26 12
Handplow 2.35 3.36 4.95 73 73 56 16 12
Claypipe 2.34 4.61 8.85 61 61 39 16 10
Butter Churn 2.32 2.76 7.63 74 74 68 13 12
Bottles 2.32 3.24 10.33 74 74 51 17 12
Loom 2.31 1.87 9.74 68 68 54 14 11
Sheep Walker 2.26 3.38 11.18 76 76 44 22 12
Mantlepiece 2.23 2.95 6.85 77 77 46 19 12
Hedge Keeper 2.21 4.14 6.61 71 71 41 22 11
Scholar 2.13 2.72 7.79 67 67 39 16 10
Conservator 2.04 3.36 9.98 70 70 42 14 10
Moldboard Plow 2.01 1.97 8.05 71 71 62 11 10
Storehouse Keeper 2.01 3.20 2.26 71 71 38 20 10
Consultant 2.01 4.66 12.46 71 71 24 20 10
Bread Paddle 1.99 4.94 8.55 79 79 53 19 11
Animal Tamer 1.98 4.29 8.61 65 65 38 15 9
Pig Breeder 1.95 5.45 12.41 66 66 22 25 9
Carpenter 1.94 3.16 4.51 81 81 47 23 11
Acorns Basket 1.93 5.01 11.59 74 74 32 22 10
Junk Room 1.92 4.79 6.27 67 67 51 13 9
Scythe Worker 1.86 4.75 9.69 77 77 39 21 10
Firewood Collector 1.81 4.00 3.44 87 87 41 21 11
Corn Scoop 1.74 4.24 7.24 74 74 46 20 9
Clearing Spade 1.74 4.74 8.65 74 74 37 20 9
Wood Cutter 1.63 2.53 1.51 79 79 63 14 9
Plow Driver 1.57 2.59 9.87 73 73 47 11 8
Stonecutter 1.54 3.20 5.71 65 65 42 10 7
Harpooner 1.52 2.15 3.75 66 66 53 11 7
Manservant 1.47 3.57 8.27 68 68 30 16 7
Herring Pot 1.47 4.78 6.83 78 78 35 18 8
Young Animal Market 1.41 5.77 11.54 81 81 35 20 8
Scullery 1.39 4.78 3.95 72 72 37 15 7
Drinking Trough 1.39 5.36 9.95 72 72 40 15 7
Market Stall 1.39 6.17 10.63 72 72 27 15 7
Large Greenhouse 1.33 4.95 6.11 75 75 35 10 7
Greengrocer 1.28 4.28 8.13 78 78 38 16 7
Adoptive Parents 1.26 3.88 8.11 68 68 37 14 6
Dutch Windmill 1.26 5.74 12.38 68 68 16 19 6
Animal Dealer 1.25 3.94 10.36 80 80 25 12 7
Lutenist 1.25 5.40 4.64 80 80 28 18 7
Pitchfork 1.16 5.22 7.90 74 74 42 18 6
Brook 1.13 5.04 6.40 76 76 30 10 6
Sheep Whisperer 1.08 5.36 4.44 66 66 18 13 5
Lasso 1.07 4.69 9.43 67 67 37 13 5
Basket 1.07 6.10 7.74 67 67 23 14 5
Shifting Cultivation 1.05 4.76 9.14 68 68 50 10 5
Conjurer 0.93 3.99 3.53 77 77 38 13 5
Groom 0.92 4.58 10.26 78 78 27 18 5
Wool Blankets 0.80 6.01 13.00 71 71 11 14 4
Tutor 0.74 5.25 3.42 77 77 26 16 4
Stone Tongs 0.69 5.21 8.56 62 62 32 10 3
Organic Farmer 0.63 4.79 13.78 68 68 23 16 3
Geologist 0.60 5.17 3.62 72 72 24 14 3
Mushroom Collector 0.57 5.29 3.76 75 75 25 13 3
Cattle Feeder 0.45 5.20 10.58 64 64 26 12 2
Oven Firing Boy 0.45 6.02 11.22 63 63 9 19 2
Roughcaster 0.36 6.48 7.12 79 79 8 22 2
Frame Builder 0.22 4.83 8.10 66 66 21 16 1
Stable Architect 0.20 5.92 13.60 72 72 15 15 1
Paper Maker 0.00 5.95 7.25 74 74 12 21 0
Wall Builder 0.00 6.49 6.50 77 77 6 17 0
Code: Select all
Card Name PWR ADP APR Deals Drafted Plays Win-Hand Win-Play
Begging Student 5.55 1.71 3.25 399 379 355 165 155
Braggart 4.55 1.94 13.47 836 641 525 287 266
Field Watchman 4.54 1.33 3.42 412 407 390 137 131
Bookshelf 4.42 2.40 8.12 420 410 370 132 130
Mason 4.39 3.28 12.25 407 366 285 141 125
Lettuce Patch 4.32 3.47 10.10 446 424 362 147 135
Bookcase 4.31 1.83 4.70 434 428 401 135 131
Cultivator 4.12 2.41 5.25 402 392 350 120 116
Furnisher 4.08 3.30 4.59 385 342 279 125 110
Carpenter's Parlor 3.94 1.36 4.45 1786 1592 1451 529 493
Patron 3.86 2.38 2.36 407 386 362 114 110
Excavator 3.84 1.83 2.64 402 394 332 121 108
Swing Plow 3.70 2.57 9.31 455 425 369 132 118
Wood Barterer 3.70 2.63 5.02 394 376 319 113 102
Wooden Hut Extender 3.69 2.47 5.34 376 350 313 110 97
Reed Pond 3.63 3.75 8.68 417 379 295 122 106
Rammed Clay 3.61 2.01 5.18 1783 1591 1518 470 450
Chimney Sweep 3.60 4.00 11.98 369 348 247 118 93
Assistant Tiller 3.57 1.57 3.95 1693 1511 1345 467 423
Charcoal Burner 3.52 2.83 3.42 386 355 277 111 95
Bonehead 3.44 3.34 3.70 394 370 309 109 95
Grocer 3.42 2.62 9.54 1701 1460 1091 494 407
Constable 3.42 4.13 6.30 397 318 224 108 95
Milking Stool 3.38 3.96 10.92 448 384 294 124 106
Caravan 3.32 1.56 5.50 873 694 567 233 203
Clay Supports 3.28 2.21 6.63 462 433 361 129 106
Field Fences 3.28 3.11 11.75 444 420 332 114 102
Bricklayer 3.28 3.17 5.60 375 340 267 95 86
Lantern House 3.27 2.66 1.81 467 387 308 124 107
Writing Desk 3.26 3.30 7.55 451 406 347 113 103
Loam Pit 3.20 2.20 8.52 1809 1605 1207 489 405
Loom 3.20 3.01 10.05 1777 1488 1127 481 398
Potter Ceramics 3.18 3.19 5.64 462 409 362 115 103
Pet Lover 3.15 2.77 5.87 403 359 294 99 89
Half-Timbered House 3.11 3.50 13.28 446 399 224 121 97
Education Bonus 3.11 3.61 6.76 436 380 307 112 95
Water Worker 3.08 2.75 3.56 408 381 295 105 88
Big Country 3.06 2.77 9.14 1789 1338 774 504 383
Wood Cart 3.03 2.74 8.10 485 467 360 129 103
Master Builder 2.97 4.78 13.11 414 300 214 102 86
Mining Hammer 2.94 3.30 7.23 1773 1487 1165 432 365
Harpooner 2.90 2.18 3.67 1737 1513 1214 424 353
Private Forest 2.82 3.24 3.42 435 367 269 102 86
Wood Expert 2.79 3.46 4.79 374 325 248 93 73
Seasonal Worker 2.78 2.19 4.47 1721 1538 1139 445 335
Moldboard Plow 2.78 2.25 7.62 1786 1583 1405 385 347
Blueprint 2.77 2.81 6.63 449 423 326 101 87
Carrot Museum 2.74 3.11 7.22 417 357 249 107 80
Porter 2.74 3.35 4.43 406 339 265 90 78
Furniture Maker 2.70 4.13 3.33 386 318 256 85 73
Mini Pasture 2.69 3.17 7.46 1739 1487 1250 396 328
Beanfield 2.66 4.15 10.47 1785 1409 1034 426 332
Feed Fence 2.65 4.17 7.97 448 360 296 96 83
Skillful Renovator 2.63 4.40 8.74 440 334 218 101 81
House Steward 2.62 3.70 4.92 1762 1393 928 451 323
Turnwrest Plow 2.59 2.97 9.00 458 409 345 96 83
Brushwood Collector 2.52 2.23 4.36 1722 1521 1146 398 304
Conservator 2.52 2.82 9.85 1719 1502 1107 385 303
Small-scale Farmer 2.51 3.03 1.58 1715 1329 1070 366 301
Wood Collector 2.51 3.66 4.32 376 336 253 82 66
Clay Firer 2.48 4.58 9.34 386 308 167 95 67
Foreign Aid 2.46 4.38 5.09 448 260 201 87 77
Winter Caretaker 2.43 4.54 8.75 399 292 212 78 68
Reed-Hatted Toad 2.36 3.07 1.92 430 376 292 99 71
Milk Jug 2.36 3.40 9.69 1774 1483 1204 357 293
Clay Supply 2.35 3.88 5.14 455 404 325 96 75
Schnapps Distillery 2.32 4.01 11.34 456 385 250 101 74
Supply Boat 2.31 4.26 8.42 421 329 261 77 68
Sleeping Corner 2.29 2.59 11.10 1773 1513 817 410 284
Feed Pellets 2.29 4.75 8.00 462 346 285 84 74
Straw-Thatched Roof 2.28 2.92 8.43 451 397 271 90 72
Lumber Mill 2.28 3.63 6.55 1802 1387 912 391 287
Wood Field 2.28 3.88 8.98 295 246 191 54 47
Canoe 2.27 2.55 5.51 1806 1569 1168 369 287
Trident 2.27 4.35 9.69 478 396 303 94 76
Master Bricklayer 2.26 4.04 9.21 1721 1353 661 432 272
Wood Cutter 2.25 2.31 2.45 1743 1551 1263 331 275
Game Catcher 2.24 4.82 13.60 402 340 228 82 63
Chicken Coop 2.23 3.83 6.33 435 366 252 89 68
Butter Churn 2.21 3.73 7.88 1755 1359 1017 344 271
Bellfounder 2.21 3.97 6.57 388 268 164 83 60
Hutch 2.16 3.95 7.88 443 394 269 89 67
Cottager 2.15 2.61 4.52 1742 1491 966 413 262
Small Greenhouse 2.15 4.39 7.18 459 336 213 99 69
Horse-Drawn Boat 2.14 4.22 8.24 414 333 208 93 62
Roof Ballaster 2.12 3.94 11.90 1712 1357 669 453 254
Bottles 2.09 3.52 10.08 1733 1424 812 383 253
Scholar 2.09 3.76 8.57 1720 1259 664 413 252
Recycled Brick 2.09 5.10 10.92 445 296 181 92 65
Pond Hut 2.08 3.75 6.88 1768 1399 903 378 258
Cross-Cut Wood 2.08 4.83 11.31 453 307 197 93 66
Strawberry Patch 2.07 4.02 12.73 1823 1404 665 424 264
Stockman 2.05 4.77 10.80 383 294 191 70 55
Childless 2.03 3.15 3.90 1742 1140 696 349 248
Plow Maker 2.02 3.55 8.31 431 370 287 78 61
Clay Carrier 2.00 5.05 7.80 393 273 158 76 55
Manger 1.98 4.31 11.68 1837 1172 676 346 255
Shepherd's Crook 1.97 3.62 7.88 1758 1340 1049 308 243
Schnapps Distiller 1.96 3.89 7.79 386 328 217 71 53
Plow Driver 1.93 3.63 10.06 1737 1274 685 368 235
Potato Harvester 1.93 4.44 8.37 399 318 231 73 54
Layabout 1.92 4.33 9.33 410 333 216 84 55
Clay Deliveryman 1.91 3.93 5.60 426 358 223 95 57
Junk Room 1.89 3.84 5.55 1793 1381 1022 310 237
Storehouse Keeper 1.87 3.23 3.32 1741 1393 781 368 228
Animal Tamer 1.87 3.83 8.34 1710 1442 845 340 224
Claypipe 1.87 4.59 8.09 1745 1186 738 336 229
Carriage Trip 1.87 4.68 9.64 443 301 224 73 58
Threshing Board 1.86 4.23 10.36 1733 1301 805 332 226
Wildlife Reserve 1.86 4.39 10.56 438 356 225 84 57
Hard Porcelain 1.85 3.98 9.32 1817 1401 877 351 235
Manservant 1.81 3.94 8.76 1721 1269 644 371 218
Handplow 1.78 3.43 5.75 1799 1408 958 311 224
Flail 1.77 4.47 7.09 445 333 267 63 55
Farm Store 1.75 4.08 7.78 448 335 217 82 55
Stone Cart 1.74 3.99 6.26 451 353 209 85 55
Baker 1.74 4.33 9.72 434 347 211 79 53
Three-Field Rotation 1.71 4.40 10.56 1774 1328 813 311 212
Plowman 1.70 3.81 3.61 404 305 222 64 48
Domestician Expert 1.70 4.86 7.82 421 257 145 72 50
Market Crier 1.69 3.79 7.35 389 314 252 56 46
Herring Pot 1.68 3.46 6.13 1778 1407 929 310 209
Clay Kneader 1.68 4.24 5.48 382 313 226 57 45
Carpenter 1.64 2.65 4.61 1757 1500 1085 308 202
Truffle Slicer 1.63 4.68 10.40 455 319 192 68 52
Stonecutter 1.61 3.55 6.38 1736 1442 760 344 196
Clay Hut Builder 1.60 3.83 7.54 1740 1368 713 326 195
Bread Paddle 1.60 4.54 8.36 1772 1222 802 290 199
Stork's Nest 1.59 4.00 9.64 448 326 163 86 50
Granary 1.59 4.80 7.97 440 264 162 69 49
Hedge Keeper 1.58 3.20 8.19 1758 1549 1031 309 194
Greengrocer 1.57 2.98 6.80 1724 1498 1102 268 190
Adoptive Parents 1.55 3.97 8.13 1747 1333 742 330 189
Cowherd 1.55 5.12 10.70 387 258 104 69 42
Seed Trader 1.54 5.04 10.26 380 186 108 56 41
Animal Dealer 1.53 3.67 9.78 1720 1441 659 338 184
Steam Machine 1.53 4.20 9.83 430 329 190 82 46
Priest 1.53 4.35 7.26 1759 1105 591 335 189
Stable Master 1.53 4.97 8.27 401 269 173 63 43
Tutor 1.52 4.41 2.68 1743 1193 770 290 186
Corn Scoop 1.50 3.12 6.49 1810 1511 1175 264 190
Stone Tongs 1.49 4.14 8.42 1770 1363 826 291 185
Thresher 1.48 4.24 7.65 397 283 179 62 41
Shifting Cultivation 1.47 4.21 8.98 1752 1289 924 282 180
Sheep Well 1.47 5.09 11.57 456 289 164 66 47
Clay Plasterer 1.45 4.03 7.22 434 352 243 63 44
Fishing Net 1.44 3.97 7.42 416 320 219 60 42
Puppeteer 1.42 4.28 3.65 392 293 182 61 39
Organic Farmer 1.39 5.01 13.36 1732 1140 395 351 168
Sack Cart 1.37 4.18 7.19 1788 1226 655 258 171
Scullery 1.36 3.40 4.29 1776 1366 827 287 169
Lasso 1.36 4.06 9.58 1756 1324 730 309 167
Seed Seller 1.35 3.99 6.51 392 310 222 49 37
Home Brewer 1.35 4.55 8.54 402 311 178 53 38
Thick Forest 1.34 4.56 7.19 1781 1225 599 281 167
Stone Clearing 1.34 5.15 10.55 427 289 166 66 40
Sheep Walker 1.33 3.79 10.61 1717 1346 608 316 160
Acorns Basket 1.24 4.51 11.04 1802 1319 591 319 157
Building Tycoon 1.22 3.99 5.75 421 316 154 75 36
Millwright 1.20 4.57 8.32 392 272 167 52 33
Hunting Trophy 1.20 4.88 11.58 298 193 92 47 25
Consultant 1.18 4.55 11.71 1814 1308 541 333 150
Mantlepiece 1.15 4.12 7.31 1761 1064 452 320 142
Stable 1.15 5.13 9.51 446 284 206 48 36
Milking Place 1.14 4.61 9.22 489 303 170 62 39
Livestock Feeder 1.14 4.91 9.11 401 262 138 57 32
Pitchfork 1.13 4.03 7.26 1797 1335 881 216 142
Pastor 1.10 4.71 8.17 1734 1082 442 301 134
Stone Carver 1.08 4.84 7.12 409 231 116 54 31
Pattern Maker 1.07 5.09 9.04 375 202 89 43 28
Firewood Collector 1.06 3.84 4.60 1774 1357 676 258 132
Mushroom Collector 1.05 3.96 3.32 1762 1289 561 285 130
Groom 1.05 4.84 10.51 1780 1179 407 304 131
Brook 1.04 3.96 5.55 1802 1304 583 262 131
Scythe Worker 1.03 4.37 8.19 1768 1235 580 256 127
Collector 1.02 4.32 8.91 407 224 128 47 29
Drinking Trough 0.99 4.31 9.77 1810 1249 680 224 125
Clearing Spade 0.98 4.58 9.43 1810 1183 598 250 124
Merchant 0.92 4.44 6.61 418 289 140 61 27
Paper Maker 0.92 4.91 5.41 1697 1095 494 258 109
Geologist 0.91 3.73 3.01 1791 1401 739 232 114
Large Greenhouse 0.91 4.17 6.57 1817 1245 510 242 116
Fodder Planter 0.91 5.12 11.72 251 146 67 24 16
Clay Embankment 0.90 5.08 9.35 1770 1075 489 253 112
Resource Recycler 0.90 5.16 10.95 398 233 105 59 25
Transactor 0.89 5.15 13.32 385 198 88 47 24
Cube Cutter 0.88 5.38 9.21 404 197 103 43 25
Hide Farmer 0.88 5.42 13.30 275 145 64 34 17
Conjurer 0.84 3.79 4.09 1751 1254 657 251 103
Cattle Feeder 0.84 4.13 9.14 1737 1334 567 239 102
Game Trade 0.82 5.21 12.49 452 242 105 60 26
Frame Builder 0.77 4.26 8.14 1743 1266 502 236 94
Muck Rake 0.77 5.47 11.41 443 173 102 34 24
Pig Breeder 0.74 4.96 11.92 1722 1142 342 281 89
Market Stall 0.74 5.30 10.23 1780 1000 475 203 92
Sculpture 0.72 5.12 12.00 473 264 47 62 24
Freemason 0.71 4.59 6.34 402 181 89 39 20
Cattle Buyer 0.71 5.21 10.55 381 227 75 51 19
Sheep Whisperer 0.70 4.38 4.10 1717 1164 467 214 84
Young Animal Market 0.70 5.17 11.22 1828 1084 507 211 90
Lutenist 0.66 4.61 4.83 1753 1188 476 233 81
Basket 0.61 4.97 7.05 1807 983 382 195 77
Stablehand 0.60 4.77 9.06 381 230 112 36 16
Reed Roof Renovator 0.59 5.55 8.06 385 185 79 35 16
Dutch Windmill 0.50 4.95 11.65 1769 1055 255 195 62
Interior Decorator 0.50 5.26 6.21 400 145 53 27 14
Wall Builder 0.49 4.76 4.98 1735 1070 371 186 60
Stable Architect 0.44 5.53 13.22 1751 977 255 189 54
Oven Firing Boy 0.40 4.94 9.44 1720 1053 213 201 48
Bean Counter 0.40 4.97 5.36 397 179 78 31 11
Wool Blankets 0.35 5.67 12.54 1773 792 173 183 44
Dwelling Mound 0.34 4.88 2.32 461 164 81 27 11
Ravenous Hunger 0.34 4.95 9.98 469 195 82 32 11
Cattle Whisperer 0.31 5.01 6.19 411 175 63 25 9
Roughcaster 0.26 5.59 8.04 1736 899 217 171 32
Sugar Baker 0.24 5.16 8.67 424 151 39 26 7
Code: Select all
Card Name PWR ADP APR Deals Drafted Plays Win-Hand Win-Play
Caravan 5.71 1.20 4.96 25 25 25 10 10
Carpenter's Parlor 5.17 1.21 4.20 163 163 156 61 59
Lettuce Patch 5.01 3.24 9.52 77 75 66 28 27
Bookshelf 4.97 2.10 8.29 69 69 66 24 24
Field Watchman 4.95 1.21 3.45 75 75 71 27 26
Big Country 4.73 2.03 8.55 151 142 108 59 50
Assistant Tiller 4.60 1.36 3.91 146 146 137 51 47
Patron 4.52 2.25 2.13 60 57 55 19 19
Bonehead 4.45 3.27 4.33 61 59 52 20 19
Begging Student 4.31 1.53 3.49 73 73 70 22 22
Writing Desk 4.20 3.00 7.31 68 67 61 20 20
Wood Barterer 4.11 2.42 4.80 66 66 61 19 19
Reed-Hatted Toad 3.98 2.80 1.95 61 56 43 23 17
Rammed Clay 3.95 1.76 5.06 159 157 150 46 44
Winter Caretaker 3.90 4.40 8.77 66 52 43 19 18
Furnisher 3.82 2.86 4.69 71 70 62 21 19
Furniture Maker 3.79 3.72 3.22 64 53 40 20 17
Braggart 3.76 1.16 13.53 19 19 19 5 5
Mining Hammer 3.76 3.20 7.14 167 160 139 49 44
Milking Stool 3.72 3.96 11.37 73 69 54 21 19
Grocer 3.70 2.15 9.17 166 166 145 47 43
Loam Pit 3.69 2.05 8.36 155 155 128 48 40
Wood Collector 3.64 3.86 4.32 55 51 40 14 14
Reed Pond 3.63 3.51 9.04 63 57 45 18 16
Charcoal Burner 3.62 2.45 3.53 67 65 53 18 17
Potter Ceramics 3.62 3.33 5.16 71 69 61 20 18
Bookcase 3.52 1.71 4.71 73 73 66 19 18
Lantern House 3.52 2.22 1.63 73 69 59 19 18
Mason 3.52 3.16 12.56 65 62 52 17 16
Cultivator 3.51 2.43 5.24 61 61 55 16 15
Brushwood Collector 3.40 2.39 4.06 147 145 109 45 35
Swing Plow 3.38 2.60 9.15 76 70 59 19 18
Conservator 3.38 3.29 10.07 152 148 104 41 36
House Steward 3.35 3.61 4.59 162 157 119 45 38
Wooden Hut Extender 3.34 2.43 5.05 47 44 41 12 11
Constable 3.33 4.02 5.61 73 61 44 21 17
Water Worker 3.28 3.11 3.67 61 54 43 19 14
Clay Firer 3.28 4.51 10.03 61 49 35 14 14
Recycled Brick 3.24 5.04 10.72 75 55 39 23 17
Sleeping Corner 3.20 2.23 10.92 152 149 100 43 34
Roof Ballaster 3.17 3.70 11.75 144 140 80 42 32
Beanfield 3.16 4.09 10.58 172 165 131 49 38
Mini Pasture 3.15 3.40 8.33 145 141 124 37 32
Master Builder 3.13 5.02 13.17 73 55 42 17 16
Seasonal Worker 3.11 2.37 4.62 147 147 109 40 32
Private Forest 3.11 3.54 3.15 69 57 41 18 15
Small-scale Farmer 3.10 2.89 1.35 143 127 106 39 31
Childless 3.09 2.31 3.23 162 147 112 41 35
Chimney Sweep 3.02 4.02 12.28 52 51 39 14 11
Strawberry Patch 2.98 3.87 12.85 163 159 89 53 34
Loom 2.91 2.72 10.26 167 163 133 40 34
Milk Jug 2.90 3.73 9.64 143 135 115 34 29
Skillful Renovator 2.90 3.92 9.16 64 49 38 15 13
Straw-Thatched Roof 2.89 2.91 7.86 79 76 57 19 16
Excavator 2.86 1.81 2.57 70 69 61 15 14
Pet Lover 2.86 2.67 5.57 65 61 56 14 13
Flail 2.86 4.73 7.55 75 56 42 18 15
Pond Hut 2.82 3.64 6.92 142 128 93 38 28
Priest 2.82 4.09 6.73 152 135 85 37 30
Small Greenhouse 2.82 4.20 6.52 76 61 46 19 15
Education Bonus 2.81 3.73 6.43 61 60 51 15 12
Stockman 2.81 5.18 11.50 56 44 28 14 11
Foreign Aid 2.78 4.37 4.84 72 46 37 14 14
Blueprint 2.73 2.78 6.49 68 67 51 14 13
Lumber Mill 2.72 3.42 6.32 168 146 114 36 32
Clay Carrier 2.72 5.00 6.73 63 45 26 17 12
Clay Supports 2.69 1.91 6.66 69 68 59 15 13
Carrot Museum 2.66 2.64 7.26 59 56 47 12 11
Half-Timbered House 2.65 3.47 13.37 70 66 38 14 13
Hutch 2.63 4.15 8.26 76 67 46 16 14
Bellfounder 2.62 4.02 6.47 60 47 30 12 11
Moldboard Plow 2.60 2.40 8.04 154 152 137 29 28
Wood Cart 2.54 2.58 8.28 90 89 74 19 16
Threshing Board 2.49 4.63 10.20 155 126 81 38 27
Turnwrest Plow 2.48 3.18 9.60 75 67 60 15 13
Horse-Drawn Boat 2.48 4.44 8.07 75 64 42 17 13
Cross-Cut Wood 2.48 4.57 11.26 69 53 39 15 12
Schnapps Distillery 2.48 4.61 11.54 69 61 37 19 12
Wood Field 2.44 4.13 8.72 41 30 25 7 7
Clay Deliveryman 2.38 4.17 6.26 72 66 43 17 12
Shepherd's Crook 2.37 4.04 7.97 151 127 101 32 25
Bricklayer 2.35 3.06 5.29 67 65 49 12 11
Master Bricklayer 2.35 4.17 9.16 146 140 69 44 24
Wood Cutter 2.32 2.76 2.15 160 156 121 37 26
Hard Porcelain 2.32 4.20 9.09 160 144 96 32 26
Carpenter 2.31 3.02 4.92 161 157 103 41 26
Market Crier 2.30 4.15 7.30 56 41 33 10 9
Plow Maker 2.29 3.59 9.26 75 63 50 13 12
Feed Pellets 2.29 4.91 8.05 75 55 44 13 12
Hedge Keeper 2.28 4.20 8.23 169 159 105 44 27
Clay Kneader 2.28 4.47 6.00 69 58 45 12 11
Manger 2.27 4.10 11.39 170 116 79 35 27
Bottles 2.26 3.58 10.08 164 152 102 39 26
Storehouse Keeper 2.26 3.58 3.19 152 141 81 40 24
Pastor 2.25 4.84 7.84 165 135 75 43 26
Field Fences 2.20 2.90 12.20 65 62 51 12 10
Animal Tamer 2.19 4.42 9.06 150 140 80 34 23
Canoe 2.16 3.08 5.64 172 167 138 32 26
Clay Plasterer 2.16 4.29 7.03 66 58 36 13 10
Handplow 2.14 3.71 5.46 167 154 114 34 25
Clay Supply 2.14 3.96 5.41 80 73 61 13 12
Fodder Planter 2.13 5.44 11.22 47 25 18 8 7
Trident 2.12 4.61 9.63 74 62 52 13 11
Butter Churn 2.10 3.54 7.81 163 151 124 27 24
Plowman 2.10 3.89 4.21 68 55 42 11 10
Bread Paddle 2.10 4.81 8.20 170 142 95 37 25
Thick Forest 2.09 5.00 7.06 171 137 77 37 25
Clay Hut Builder 2.08 3.88 7.27 151 142 85 31 22
Seed Trader 2.07 5.56 10.50 62 32 20 11 9
Stone Cart 2.06 4.17 6.73 90 69 45 20 13
Cottager 2.04 2.33 3.96 168 165 117 36 24
Stork's Nest 2.04 3.89 9.26 70 54 31 15 10
Feed Fence 2.04 4.52 8.13 77 63 53 13 11
Pattern Maker 2.04 5.27 8.95 56 33 21 10 8
Animal Dealer 2.01 4.05 10.00 149 148 58 32 21
Potato Harvester 2.01 4.78 8.73 78 64 44 17 11
Scholar 1.99 3.49 8.20 151 135 79 35 21
Home Brewer 1.96 5.22 8.78 51 37 23 9 7
Farm Store 1.95 3.76 6.39 66 50 33 14 9
Greengrocer 1.95 3.92 7.96 161 150 97 33 22
Sheep Walker 1.94 3.73 10.36 155 146 88 37 21
Plow Driver 1.90 3.18 9.86 150 138 86 28 20
Steam Machine 1.89 4.07 9.79 68 57 33 13 9
Layabout 1.89 4.38 8.66 68 53 38 12 9
Sack Cart 1.89 4.64 7.67 174 135 86 34 23
Cowherd 1.89 5.85 10.77 53 27 13 9 7
Carriage Trip 1.86 5.11 11.00 77 55 37 15 10
Harpooner 1.79 2.42 3.67 152 149 123 27 19
Porter 1.79 3.16 4.24 64 55 42 10 8
Milking Place 1.79 4.64 8.37 80 56 30 15 10
Cube Cutter 1.76 5.39 11.05 65 33 20 11 8
Scullery 1.75 4.49 4.09 163 135 76 36 20
Acorns Basket 1.75 5.22 11.22 171 141 73 43 21
Clay Embankment 1.69 5.42 9.74 177 129 61 35 21
Junk Room 1.68 4.46 5.35 162 131 113 24 19
Three-Field Rotation 1.68 4.84 10.84 170 154 95 34 20
Baker 1.66 4.34 9.93 69 61 41 13 8
Truffle Slicer 1.66 4.81 10.51 86 63 39 11 10
Wood Expert 1.64 2.87 4.58 61 53 43 9 7
Stonecutter 1.63 3.57 6.32 149 143 91 25 17
Chicken Coop 1.61 3.68 6.28 71 60 43 9 8
Supply Boat 1.61 4.69 8.02 80 68 56 10 9
Scythe Worker 1.58 4.96 9.82 154 122 62 31 17
Pig Breeder 1.58 5.44 12.38 154 124 47 40 17
Puppeteer 1.57 4.07 3.51 73 57 39 12 8
Mantlepiece 1.56 3.45 6.88 156 121 72 29 17
Shifting Cultivation 1.55 4.90 9.67 157 130 96 29 17
Claypipe 1.52 4.59 8.26 150 128 88 27 16
Wildlife Reserve 1.47 4.47 10.48 68 58 40 7 7
Corn Scoop 1.45 3.97 6.79 168 152 102 36 17
Fishing Net 1.45 4.32 7.30 69 57 37 11 7
Consultant 1.45 4.88 12.92 167 133 52 32 17
Firewood Collector 1.44 4.07 3.91 179 152 82 34 18
Game Catcher 1.43 5.42 13.61 60 52 41 9 6
Clearing Spade 1.42 4.98 8.63 171 130 67 33 17
Organic Farmer 1.40 4.92 13.36 143 127 53 31 14
Adoptive Parents 1.39 4.20 7.95 144 128 76 26 14
Stone Carver 1.39 5.58 7.19 82 43 21 12 8
Schnapps Distiller 1.36 3.98 7.65 63 54 34 9 6
Stable Master 1.33 5.37 8.45 75 43 31 9 7
Paper Maker 1.33 5.40 6.57 140 115 42 35 13
Large Greenhouse 1.32 4.79 6.28 173 135 71 23 16
Herring Pot 1.31 4.60 6.41 163 146 82 29 15
Pitchfork 1.31 5.04 7.70 164 133 83 28 15
Manservant 1.30 3.98 8.38 154 131 60 29 14
Stable 1.30 5.67 10.07 66 39 29 6 6
Lasso 1.27 4.73 9.44 157 133 75 27 14
Tutor 1.27 4.91 2.95 146 123 58 30 13
Granary 1.19 4.93 8.55 60 27 20 5 5
Livestock Feeder 1.19 5.26 9.88 72 50 25 11 6
Domestician Expert 1.17 4.69 8.78 61 39 18 8 5
Hide Farmer 1.14 5.48 13.42 50 31 12 7 4
Young Animal Market 1.09 5.81 11.86 184 119 51 32 14
Mushroom Collector 1.07 4.68 4.28 160 136 65 26 12
Transactor 1.07 5.59 13.56 67 34 18 10 5
Sheep Well 1.06 5.22 11.97 81 49 29 11 6
Merchant 1.05 4.37 6.40 68 43 20 13 5
Resource Recycler 1.05 5.27 10.30 68 41 20 12 5
Sculpture 1.03 5.20 12.00 83 49 11 16 6
Collector 1.02 4.40 8.36 70 45 22 10 5
Building Tycoon 1.01 3.98 5.07 71 47 27 10 5
Stone Tongs 1.01 4.95 8.51 142 126 71 23 10
Stone Clearing 1.01 5.51 10.88 71 47 25 12 5
Millwright 1.00 4.86 8.08 57 36 25 8 4
Groom 0.99 4.61 10.48 159 120 46 32 11
Market Stall 0.92 6.14 10.60 155 102 43 19 10
Drinking Trough 0.91 5.51 10.09 173 116 65 22 11
Hunting Trophy 0.89 4.45 11.72 48 31 18 7 3
Conjurer 0.85 4.04 4.11 152 122 65 23 9
Seed Seller 0.85 4.66 7.03 67 53 36 6 4
Brook 0.83 4.91 6.64 173 128 59 18 10
Oven Firing Boy 0.79 5.93 10.36 145 94 25 30 8
Cattle Feeder 0.77 5.07 10.20 148 127 60 26 8
Sheep Whisperer 0.72 5.36 5.00 138 96 30 20 7
Dutch Windmill 0.72 5.60 12.22 159 106 27 23 8
Basket 0.71 5.96 7.38 161 91 34 20 8
Cattle Buyer 0.68 5.56 12.10 63 34 10 7 3
Lutenist 0.66 5.48 4.91 152 116 45 23 7
Stablehand 0.63 5.76 10.38 68 29 8 9 3
Freemason 0.58 4.78 7.25 74 32 16 5 3
Game Trade 0.57 5.68 12.43 75 31 14 8 3
Dwelling Mound 0.54 4.66 2.35 80 35 20 5 3
Frame Builder 0.54 4.90 8.33 158 134 55 26 6
Cattle Whisperer 0.48 5.55 6.40 59 20 5 5 2
Stable Architect 0.47 6.00 13.45 151 109 33 23 5
Wool Blankets 0.47 6.04 13.00 153 80 15 18 5
Roughcaster 0.46 6.17 8.04 155 113 23 30 5
Thresher 0.45 4.60 8.44 63 47 34 5 2
Geologist 0.45 5.04 2.92 158 132 59 20 5
Interior Decorator 0.41 5.42 7.00 69 19 5 4 2
Bean Counter 0.26 5.50 6.75 56 18 8 2 1
Reed Roof Renovator 0.23 5.96 7.36 63 25 11 4 1
Muck Rake 0.23 6.04 11.85 63 24 13 3 1
Sugar Baker 0.21 6.10 8.50 67 20 6 4 1
Ravenous Hunger 0.19 5.46 10.43 76 24 7 7 1
Wall Builder 0.09 6.18 5.65 168 109 20 20 1