Page 1 of 1

A Feast for Odin Beta feedback

Posted: 19 January 2022, 23:22
by Papa Boris
I'm not sure if this is the right place to leave feedback on the actual implementation of individual games; if not, please let me know and I'll move this post.

Two players each got bitten by a weird implementation of the raiding system.

Once you declare your raid a success, you can no longer add swords/stone to it. This can have a huge impact if you're trying to get one of the big 8–9 sword treasures and are stuck instead getting the dinky 6. On its own it wouldn't be a problem, except that for some reason you can't undo after reporting the raid a success.

To fix this, one of two things should be done:

1) Allow swords/stone to be added to the die roll after reporting the success of the raid. This would be ideal, but if for some technical reason it won't work, then

2) Allow undo to the game state prior to the point when success was declared. No new information has been revealed, so there's no reason why an undo shouldn't be allowed here.

Overall, though, this is an amazing implementation of an amazing game. I cannot even begin to imagine how much work it must have taken to put this thing together—my huge thanks to the developer!

Re: A Feast for Odin Beta feedback

Posted: 21 January 2022, 19:15
by Een
I moved your post to the game dedicated forum, but the best way to reach the developer with suggestions is to list them in the tracker tool:
https://boardgamearena.com/bugs

Re: A Feast for Odin Beta feedback

Posted: 24 January 2022, 01:37
by Duke22
I concur with this recommendation when Raiding. It was bit by the same thing ... had to get a dinky tile because I couldn't undo. Great game though!

Re: A Feast for Odin Beta feedback

Posted: 29 January 2022, 18:12
by EricMulvihill
Trying my first Solo game. I can take actions, and I can place goods on the Feast area. But I cannot see any of my goods at all to place on my player board (just silver, of which I have none)! Nor can I drag and drop goods to my player board! Is this something where I have not fulfilled a requirement? Or is the game bugged? Chrome/Windows 10. edit: I can drag silver, so I know that works.
Edit 2: N/M I just reread the rulebook, I can't use the Orange/Red tiles for my home board. Perhaps there should be some reminder of this, though. But problem solved!