diamant wrote: ↑15 July 2022, 19:58
Tisaac wrote: ↑15 July 2022, 18:21Oh you are talking about the very well crafted scenario containing a sabotage action which is full of contradiction rulewise? The terrain pack rulebook is different from the summary card that is different again from the FAQ on that topic. Tell me again about careful crafted scenario...
I understand that it’s a bit confusing to find out all this mess of rules all at once. But it must be considered that most Memoir '44 players who have bought extensions and various supplements have become accustomed to the new rules that each addition to the game brought over periods counted in years.
I just checked the rules of the Schwammenauel Dam scenario, and I found no contradiction with the rules of the Terrain Pack booklet and the FAQs. There is just too much cross-referencing from one part of the booklet to another.
TP, page 7 :
"This rule may be used to blow-up a fuel depot, a factory complex, a radar station or any other strategic objective.
To destroy the objective, the unit must be on the corresponding hex and roll its Close Assault combat dice. If a Star is rolled, the objective
is hit and destroyed. Take the Battle Star as a Victory medal, and remove the destroyed terrain hex from the map.For another example of a potential Sabotage rule, check out the Blowing up a dam entry in the Landmarks section of this booklet."
=> this indicate nothing about the timing, and talk about 1 dice for 1 objective
Summary card :
"Roll 2 dices at the beginning of the turn... once the scenario-specificed number is reached, the Landmark is demolished"
Now it sounds like it has lifepoint, and talk about 2 dices at the beginning of the turn
French FAQ about that specific scenario :
"Q. L'Axe peut-il saboter les deux barrages ?
R. Oui, si les deux barrages sont occupés suffisamment longtemps pour que chacun d'eux reçoive quatre jetons étoile."
Now it talks about 4 life points but that's never indicated anywhere else.
So really, I have no idea how it should work in this case (waiting for publisher answer for a couple days).