Page 1 of 1
3 player games and the action tile
Posted: 23 July 2022, 16:58
by JustHere4Tichu
I would like to propose a change to 3 player games of Carnegie. That is to either remove the action tile from the games, or that every player has one. The action tile is an advantage too much.
Re: 3 player games and the action tile
Posted: 06 August 2022, 21:18
by radiusg
The third player choose the action 6 times when the others players do it 7 times. This is why the third player has an action tile.
Re: 3 player games and the action tile
Posted: 15 August 2022, 13:48
by JustHere4Tichu
I didn't ask for a reason for why the third player has the action tile. I asked if it could be changed. The third player already gets to put out a free construction project and choose a department first.
Re: 3 player games and the action tile
Posted: 26 August 2022, 12:38
by radiusg
"I asked if it could be changed" no
"The action tile is an advantage too much." i don't think so. I you remove the action tile, the third player will begin with a drawback and i don't think it's the good solution, if it's a problem for you, you should play parties only with 2 or 4 players. Problem solved.
Re: 3 player games and the action tile
Posted: 11 September 2022, 14:45
by TryWhite
I agree that the 3rd player action selection tile is overpowered. 2nd player has a huge disadvantage in all 3 player games. The 3rd player already gets first choice of departments which often means they can snag an important "single" department or guarantee themselves a department they want. Why do they need the action tile?