Vote which scenarios to eliminate from Arena - Urgent

[CesareRaf]

Very important news about arena format guys!

We can now decide together which scenarios to eliminate from arena for being non adequate to competitive playing: hurray!! However, we need to do this quickly, because the developers need to know it as soon as possible.

From a previous post I extracted this list of candidates to be eliminated. Please copy paste the list and answer with a yes or no (we don't care about the why now) to the question: do you want to eliminate this scenario from arena?

Sainte-Mer-Eglise 
Pegasus Bridge
First Assault Wave 
Arnhem Bridge 
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field 
Knightsbridge 
Panzers vs Grants
1st Armored to the rescue 
Vassieux
Pointe-du-Hoc
Mont Mouchet 
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem
Escape via the Coastal Road 
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon
Wake Island
Slopes of Mount Austen

[Wiking44]

Very important news about arena format guys!

We can now decide together which scenarios to eliminate from arena for being non adequate to competitive playing: hurray!! However, we need to do this quickly, because the developers need to know it as soon as possible.

From a previous post I extracted this list of candidates to be eliminated. Please copy paste the list and answer with a yes or no (we don't care about the why now) to the question: do you want to eliminate this scenario from arena?

Sainte-Mer-Eglise 
Pegasus Bridge
First Assault Wave 
Arnhem Bridge 
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field 
Knightsbridge 
Panzers vs Grants
1st Armored to the rescue 
Vassieux
Pointe-du-Hoc
Mont Mouchet 
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem
Escape via the Coastal Road 
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon
Wake Island
Slopes of Mount Austen

Agree with this list plus any 4 medal scenarios I know there is one 4 medal where the US has air power while unit sits on a hill.

Can we add official scenarios from DoW like “ Twin Villages” to the add to Arena list

[Waikirikiri]

I will not vote for any elimination[.
We should be able to vote to keep, not eliminate./b].

There are scenarios I do not like, but surely we are better players for having to play scenarios we don't like.

Memoir 44 isn't about playing the easy, nice scenarios - it is about playing and winning all the scenarios.

The DoW M44 online game has an award for playing and winning all the original M44 scenarios from both sides on their original day of battle. It isn't easy to do, but is more rewarding because it is hard.

I don't like some of these scenarios, but I will play them.

Reducing the number of scenarios makes Arena less interesting. Is that what we really want?

Let's stop whinging, and keep playing.

If you want easier games then go and play something else.

[Jeronimon]

Edited for clarity

Here are the votes of the Jeronimon jury

Do you want to eliminate this scenario from arena?
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem: no
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon: no
Slopes of Mount Austen: no
Escape via the Coastal Road: maybe
First Assault Wave: maybe
Arnhem Bridge: maybe
Mont Mouchet: yes
Pointe-du-Hoc: yes
Sainte-Mer-Eglise: yes yes yes
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field : yes yes yes
Knightsbridge : yes yes yes
Panzers vs Grants : yes yes yes
Vassieux: yes yes
1st Armored to the rescue : yes yes yes
Wake Island: yes


Thanks for all the hard work you put into this CesareRaf!

[Jeronimon]

I will not vote for any elimination.

There are scenarios I do not like, but surely we are better players for having to play scenarios we don't like.

Memoir 44 isn't about playing the easy, nice scenarios - it is about playing and winning all the scenarios.

The DoW M44 online game has an award for playing and winning all the original M44 scenarios from both sides on their original day of battle. It isn't easy to do, but is more rewarding because it is hard.

I don't like some of these scenarios, but I will play them.

Reducing the number of scenarios makes Arena less interesting. Is that what we really want?

Let's stop whinging, and keep playing.

If you want easier games then go and play something else.

Like you I prefer Memoir'44 to be hard and struggle. But the scenarios I vot not to play are less a battle of wits and more who has more luck with the cards and dice. Today I played (and won) with the Germans at 1st armor to the rescue in two turns (2 consecutive armor assaults)
I get nog pleasure from such wins. I would rather play more turns with eb and flow of the battle and doing smart stuff to take victory from the jaws of defeat than have it handed to me on a platter.

I have played more than a few games of Memoir'44 on the board and online and know what I prefer

[Tisaac]

Thanks for all the hard work you put into this CesareRaf!

Just to be clear : YES means you agree to remove them or you want to keep them ?

[CesareRaf]

YES
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon
Slopes of Mount Austen

MAYBE
Escape via the Coastal Road
First Assault Wave
Arnhem Bridge

NO
Mont Mouchet
Pointe-du-Hoc

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
Sainte-Mer-Eglise
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field
Knightsbridge
Panzers vs Grants
Vassieux
1st Armored to the rescue
Wake Island


Thanks for all the hard work you put into this CesareRaf!

To make things clearer guys, let's try to post answers modeled on this one (which counts as my vote):

Do you want to eliminate this scenario from arena?
Sainte-Mer-Eglise: No
Pegasus Bridge: Yes
First Assault Wave: Yes
Arnhem Bridge: Yes
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field: Yes
Knightsbridge: Yes
Panzers vs Grants: Yes
1st Armored to the rescue: Yes
Vassieux: Yes
Pointe-du-Hoc: Yes
Mont Mouchet: Yes
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem: No
Escape via the Coastal Road: No
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon: No
Wake Island: No
Slopes of Mount Austen: No

Jeronim if I know your preferences and the game enough, I think you got your votes swapped!

I will not vote for any elimination[.
We should be able to vote to keep, not eliminate./b].

There are scenarios I do not like, but surely we are better players for having to play scenarios we don't like.

Memoir 44 isn't about playing the easy, nice scenarios - it is about playing and winning all the scenarios.

The DoW M44 online game has an award for playing and winning all the original M44 scenarios from both sides on their original day of battle. It isn't easy to do, but is more rewarding because it is hard.

I don't like some of these scenarios, but I will play them.

Reducing the number of scenarios makes Arena less interesting. Is that what we really want?

Let's stop whinging, and keep playing.

If you want easier games then go and play something else.

I can hear yous screams through writing as Jeronim tried to explain, we are trying to get rid of those scenarios that being particularly short depend only on the initial draw of card, and thus do not measure well enough the skill level at the table.

[SugarFiveZero]

Do you want to eliminate this scenario from arena?
Sainte-Mer-Eglise: Yes
Pegasus Bridge: Yes
First Assault Wave: No
Arnhem Bridge: Yes
Sidi Rhezeg Air Field: Yes
Knightsbridge: Yes
Panzers vs Grants: Yes
1st Armored to the rescue: Yes
Vassieux: Yes
Pointe-du-Hoc: Yes
Mont Mouchet: Yes
Flanking Maneuver at Bir Hakem: No
Escape via the Coastal Road: No
Sugar Loaf and Half Moon: No
Wake Island: No
Slopes of Mount Austen: No

[Waikirikiri]

I can hear yous screams through writing as Jeronim tried to explain, we are trying to get rid of those scenarios that being particularly short depend only on the initial draw of card, and thus do not measure well enough the skill level at the table.

I would rather have the random selection work better.

Despite the claims that arena selection is random I seem to get one of about 6 scenarios.
Random? Not for me.

Also the points system needs to be refined.
To lose a scenario by 1 figure when one has had dice that are (at best) well below average and then lose 30+ points is also wrong.

[Randwulf]

Keep them all, we swap sides. Add more !!!