Page 1 of 1

Kicking-out Opponent After They Win

Posted: 26 May 2023, 14:12
by zenumber1brat
I would like to suggest a change to the permissions available to Player A when Player B has run out of time in turn-based games. Please note that my experience is specific to tournaments, which have an upper time limit.

Currently, Player A can remove Player B at any time. This permits the following behavior:
* Player B runs-out of time at the 25% progress point
* Players A & B play the remainder of the game anyway (aka Player A has opted-in to the game despite Player B running out of time)
* Player B has played all their moves (or all but 1, depending on turn order) and Player A has one last move. Player A then decides to expel Player B simply because they're going to win.

What I suggest instead:
* Player B runs-out of time at the 25% progress point
* BGA gives Player A the opportunity to opt-in or opt-out to playing the remainder of the game. This would mean that Player A can also not be time penalized in that match-up. The time limit of the tournament would still exist, so the game can't literally last forever.

Re: Kicking-out Opponent After They Win

Posted: 26 June 2023, 19:55
by patsyish
zenumber1brat wrote: 26 May 2023, 14:12 I would like to suggest a change to the permissions available to Player A when Player B has run out of time in turn-based games. Please note that my experience is specific to tournaments, which have an upper time limit.

Currently, Player A can remove Player B at any time. This permits the following behavior:
* Player B runs-out of time at the 25% progress point
* Players A & B play the remainder of the game anyway (aka Player A has opted-in to the game despite Player B running out of time)
* Player B has played all their moves (or all but 1, depending on turn order) and Player A has one last move. Player A then decides to expel Player B simply because they're going to win.

What I suggest instead:
* Player B runs-out of time at the 25% progress point
* BGA gives Player A the opportunity to opt-in or opt-out to playing the remainder of the game. This would mean that Player A can also not be time penalized in that match-up. The time limit of the tournament would still exist, so the game can't literally last forever.
Player A could let their time run until the the tournament time exceeds. Same effect.

Re: Kicking-out Opponent After They Win

Posted: 10 July 2023, 01:01
by Ceaseless
I actually don't see anything wrong with this. Player A had the chance to end the game in their favor because of time, but chose to play the game out further for fun anyways. All they did was extend gameplay.