Page 1 of 2
Mandatory snapping
Posted: 01 March 2024, 07:37
by JDansp
I still don't believe snapping income works as intended, I've heard multiple times it's supposed to be mandatory, would be a nice minor nerf to the current ark nova metagame.
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 01 March 2024, 13:26
by Monkeyunit
The icon overview glossary does not state "may" on snap icon, so it should indeed be mandatory.
The same is true for the draw from rep or deck, but this has less impact as you can always just draw from deck if you don't want to touch the display.
Interestingly, the size 2/3 enclosure reward say MAY, so you can opt to not place those, but there is no text with the kiosk/pavillion reward so not sure if those can be skipped or not.
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 01 March 2024, 15:08
by greenjacket124
I'd have to agree, yea. The enclosure income block is the only one that states "may".
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 01 March 2024, 17:12
by GTSchemer
Monkeyunit wrote: ↑01 March 2024, 13:26
The icon overview glossary does not state "may" on snap icon, so it should indeed be mandatory.
The same is true for the draw from rep or deck, but this has less impact as you can always just draw from deck if you don't want to touch the display.
Interestingly, the size 2/3 enclosure reward say MAY, so you can opt to not place those, but there is no text with the kiosk/pavillion reward so not sure if those can be skipped or not.
Kiosk / pavilion reward were intended to be optional as well (and work that way on BGA because we checked it). I am 95% sure it was confirmed on BGG.
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 01 March 2024, 18:38
by Fydorian
Monkeyunit wrote: ↑01 March 2024, 13:26
The icon overview glossary does not state "may" on snap icon, so it should indeed be mandatory.
The same is true for the draw from rep or deck, but this has less impact as you can always just draw from deck if you don't want to touch the display.
Interestingly, the size 2/3 enclosure reward say MAY, so you can opt to not place those, but there is no text with the kiosk/pavillion reward so not sure if those can be skipped or not.
Rules for snapping specifically state not to take from the deck fwiw
-----
But on the original topic, taking all income you have seems mandatory based on the wording of the rules (no "may", all "take"), so I would assume jdansp is correct, if BGA is allowing you to skip income, that is probably not within the scope of the rules and should be considered for a change.
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 03 March 2024, 20:31
by pjt33
Anything that places buildings on the map has to either be optional or have an "if able" qualifier, because otherwise filling up your map would deadlock the game.
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 08 March 2024, 02:05
by pf1219
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 21 March 2024, 09:02
by Tisaac
Fixed
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 21 March 2024, 14:58
by JDansp
Tisaac wrote: ↑21 March 2024, 09:02Fixed
noice
Re: Mandatory snapping
Posted: 09 April 2024, 13:38
by Zeuthis
Thanks for the quick fix!
It still says "you may snap..." in the wording when you're taking income, so might be good to update that language to avoid confusion (it threw me off before I saw this post).