Page 1 of 1

Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 09:51
by Jellby
List of "All games, any play time": 928
Image

List of "All short, medium-length and long games": 860
Image

Which (and what) are the other 68? It's not just alpha, because both lists have alpha games. Could it be (alpha) games with a play time that falls exactly at the border between categories (20 or 30 min)? At least I've identified 3 such games which don't appear in the second list:
https://boardgamearena.com/gamepanel?game=sheepshead
https://boardgamearena.com/gamepanel?game=alakablast
https://boardgamearena.com/gamepanel?ga ... sbewitched

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 09:55
by ChiefPointThief
Games with undetermined lengths like chess?

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 12:16
by Jellby
Chess is 15 min, according to https://boardgamearena.com/gamepanel?game=chess, and appears in the medium-length list (also the games I showed have some specified length). Which then falsifies my hypothesis, because 20 min is not in the border between categories.

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 13:37
by RobertBr
Pure guess but perhaps there are a few games where a time hasn't been entered in the database.

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 14:16
by Jellby
While that could be the case, at least the 3 games I found show 20 and 30 min. Perhaps the play time categories and play time displayed in the game page are different fields though.

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 30 March 2024, 16:55
by hayduke
How many angels can fit on the head of a pin?

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 31 March 2024, 08:15
by cigma
RobertBr wrote: 30 March 2024, 13:37 Pure guess but perhaps there are a few games where a time hasn't been entered in the database.
Jellby wrote: 30 March 2024, 14:16 While that could be the case, at least the 3 games I found show 20 and 30 min. Perhaps the play time categories and play time displayed in the game page are different fields though.
Good you found this issue, Jellby!

I have read somewhere, that the average game time is automatically set by statistic data. I think you both are correct that those two are different fields, and the one for filtering hasn't been entered. As far as I know the game infos on the game page are usually set by the developer.

Since so many games are concerned and some games don't have active support now, I think a bug report for the site in general could be helpful, so I opened this one: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=119286 Please support it by voting for it!
hayduke wrote: 30 March 2024, 16:55 How many angels can fit on the head of a pin?
;-)
This is not about senseless ranting, but about correct filtering so that all relevant games can be found.

Re: Which games are neither short, medium-length, nor long?

Posted: 26 April 2024, 14:10
by Livini
Some games aren't filtered for some reason, not just games at the exact borders. I noticed King of Tokyo is not listed even though the time length stated would be a 'medium-length' game. (I haven't played it so I don't really know how long the game takes besides what BGA says.)