Page 1 of 2

Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 07 September 2024, 15:52
by tylerjwarren
Arena so far has been base game, which makes sense, and Cities and Knights has only been out on here since summer, but I'd like to play arena with Cities and Knights. I suspect running only a C&K arena would make some people furious, so propose running a separate arena for C&K if possible. Thanks.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 13 September 2024, 05:03
by Rcomer727
Couldn't agree more!

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 23 September 2024, 15:01
by TheDadshine
I'd prefer to see C&N completely separated from the base game, and have its own link since they are totally different games, like TTR USA and TTR Europe. Then it would automatically have its own arena.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 27 September 2024, 13:45
by wcraigtrader
TheDadshine wrote: 23 September 2024, 15:01 I'd prefer to see C&N completely separated from the base game, and have its own link since they are totally different games [...] Then it would automatically have its own arena.
Having separate games would also help with Catan players who inadvertently join a Catan+C&K game and then quit because they don't know (or want to play) C&K.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 03 October 2024, 13:45
by Katekhon
Please, do it. I don't wanna to get into a C&K games by error. First time waited an hour wasting my time to respect my partners, the others two wee agreed all to leave.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 07 October 2024, 17:19
by Warrior
I don't know how hard it would be to code it but C&K should 100% be separated for both regular games as well as Arena games. We have so many separate games that are similar but different like Ticket to Ride versions, The Crew versions, etc. so I imagine it shouldn't be too hard to throw up a new logo and just force the settings to be C&K.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 07 October 2024, 19:19
by Fluckysan
This is the most asked feature about Catan since C&K is out.
Please do it.

And 300% agree that we need an Arena for C&K, I'm excited to play at it in a competitive manner.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 09 October 2024, 04:19
by DVC
Personally I’d love to see C&K getting its own listing and ELO - it makes the gameplay much deeper and you would see a totally different set of top players. I’d also be able to play Arena again. The current gurus appear not to have a clue what they are doing - they’ve just added Friendly Robber, making it the worst possible version of the game. Hoping that they might do a season of C&K is a very long shot.

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 22 January 2025, 22:01
by cirdan
this

Re: Separate Arena for Cities and Knights

Posted: 27 January 2025, 02:23
by Parténope y Ulises
totally agree