Page 1 of 2
Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 00:06
by primrose1234
Several times it occurred to me that I am able to expel players that didn't leave the game or violate the time limit. Right now I have the same experience in a turnbased game with him having 12h on the clock left. Once I could expel a player that created a game table and kick him from his own table before the game started. Why is that?
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 06:01
by nik592
I've never seen this. Are you sure you can actually expel them, or is it just the "this player is not playing, what can I do?" which pops up shortly after it becoming another player's turn and just gives you some generic info, but no option to actually expel.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 08:23
by primrose1234
Tried it once, worked. Don't wanna try it again to be fair to the other player.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 08:50
by Hervor
Could you post (or link) screenshots? It would help to check if this is happening to others too.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 09:00
by Jellby
You can expel players *before* the game starts. If you are the table creator, you can expel anyone. Sometimes, you can (or used to) expel the table creator, I believe this happens when the creator is offline or has been inactive for some time.
Once a game has started, you can only expel players who run out of time. Otherwise, it's a bug.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 18 February 2025, 09:10
by primrose1234
Hervor wrote: ↑18 February 2025, 08:50
Could you post (or link) screenshots? It would help to check if this is happening to others too.
*, I forgot
*Moderator edit: please refrain from swearing on BGA, this is a family-friendly platform.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 19 February 2025, 16:52
by primrose1234
The bug is now live again.
https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=632529617
I am tempted to press the expel to check if it actually works.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 19 February 2025, 17:32
by Shivaware
The game you linked doesn't seem unusual to me. Can you post a screenshot that shows you are able to expel them. You said you've done it before, but I couldn't find it in your game history. Can you post a link to the game where you expelled someone before their time expired.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 19 February 2025, 20:10
by Meeplelowda
Yes, and by the time anyone follows that link it may be gone again or it may be something that is visible to you the player, but not a spectator (which any of us following that link will be). You need something that isn't going to change and shows us things as
you see them....like a screenshot.
Re: Expelling players that didn't violate the time
Posted: 19 February 2025, 20:15
by primrose1234
Getting an error whenever I want to attach an image. Must be some forum issue.