Board Game Arena

Official rules says:
If u have more than 10 token Discard at The End of your turn.

In the game online when u take more than 10 token u have to discard immediately

Fix it please

jotaro wrote: ↑24 February 2025, 10:54 Official rules says:
If u have more than 10 token Discard at The End of your turn.

In the game online when u take more than 10 token u have to discard immediately

Fix it please

It clearly states at the top of this sub-forum, in red shading to call your attention to it:

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs

This is not a bug, this is not an error during the game.
The game works well, the developer don't know the official splendor duel rules and wrote the game with wrong rules.

jotaro wrote: ↑25 February 2025, 00:17 This is not a bug, this is not an error during the game.
The game works well, the developer don't know the official splendor duel rules and wrote the game with wrong rules.

I can tell by this that you didn't even look at the bug reports. Implementing the rules wrong *is* a bug and in fact is a specific category of the bug report system:

Rules: a rule of the game has not been followed

Please thumbs up this bug report: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=159948

When you choose the action to take new tokens, the end of your turn is just after taking the tokens, you have no other step. So discarding any more than 10 just after is normal, because it is the end of your turn.

Meeplelowda wrote: ↑25 February 2025, 01:52 Implementing the rules wrong *is* a bug

Well said! I (and everyone else I've talked to about this) am still mad that the developer closed my VERY VALID AND OBVIOUS BUG with "notabug" for breaking the rules: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=129580 Such shame!

Where as every other game with custom variants has an option to turn off the stupid rule changes, there is no way to turn off these broken implementations and the developer is too prideful to admit to the bugs. I feel so bad for the game designers that their game is being rammed over. Rename BGA to HRA - House Rules Area!

yuniboshi wrote: ↑14 April 2025, 14:14

Meeplelowda wrote: ↑25 February 2025, 01:52 Implementing the rules wrong *is* a bug

Well said! I (and everyone else I've talked to about this) am still mad that the developer closed my VERY VALID AND OBVIOUS BUG with "notabug" for breaking the rules: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=129580 Such shame!

I think you would have better chances of convincing the developer if you explained why you think that discarding immediately and discarding at the end of the turn makes a difference.

I don't know why I'm so angry but it's been a year and I am still so angry