Page 1 of 1

Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 15:43
by Calmon70
I've noticed a problem with inactivity handling in BGA tournaments.

If a player stops playing and is not kicked (either because kicking is disabled or nobody kicks them), the game can be automatically closed due to inactivity before the tournament round ends!

As a result, no winner or loser is recorded, instead of usually loss of the inactive player!

This flawed mechanic can be even abused: In tournaments without kick option and enough tournament time left, the player can just stop playing and makes a losing game to a tie.

Abandoned games due to inactivity should always result in the player with the most accumulated timeouts losing!

Created a bug report: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=256643

Example Table: https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=914335103

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 19:16
by mrdoctor
If a game times-out, the result is then based on who has the most time remaining on their clock. The player who used least time will be given first place.

It's only if a player is kicked from the game that all other players are classed as winners and 'draw' with one-another.

In the game you linked to, the other players chose to abandon the game, rather than letting it time-out. This resulted in no winner/loser, because of the active choices of those players: "All players (with a positive clock) chose to abandon this game". All they had to do was wait until it timed-out - which would have happened in about a week from when the players chose to abandon it.

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 19:26
by Shivaware
In hindsight, this is an unexpected but obvious consequence of the change to add tournament durations longer than 40 days.

I will say that the expected behaviour of ranking people by their remaining time has a drawback in cases like this. If there is a player that doesn't make a single move in the whole game, they will use the most time, but the remaining people that played earlier will be ranked after those that didn't get a chance to make a move.

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 20:30
by Calmon70
mrdoctor wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 19:16 In the game you linked to, the other players chose to abandon the game
Nope, I was part of this game and it's even stated there:

"The table has been closed automatically because no move has been completed for a long period of time."

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 21:10
by mrdoctor
Calmon70 wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 20:30
mrdoctor wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 19:16 In the game you linked to, the other players chose to abandon the game
Nope, I was part of this game and it's even stated there:

"The table has been closed automatically because no move has been completed for a long period of time."
Game replay log: https://boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=914335103

"Move 321 :05/11/2026 14:42:05
All players (with a positive clock) chose to abandon this game."

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 23:24
by Calmon70
I guess this always appears as message: here as well from same tournament. Nobody abandoned manually: https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=914334103

It's only a 8 man tournament and we have 1 person with multi accounts in the LIMIT and 2 of this accounts sadly joined the tourney and than the player stopped playing completely.

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 15 November 2026, 23:51
by mrdoctor
Calmon70 wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 23:24 I guess this always appears as message: here as well from same tournament. Nobody abandoned manually: https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=914334103
Are you sure? https://boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=914334103

"Move 300 : 06/11/2026 07:07:05
All players (with a positive clock) chose to abandon this game."

Calmon70 wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 23:24 It's only a 8 man tournament and we have 1 person with multi accounts in the LIMIT and 2 of this accounts sadly joined the tourney and than the player stopped playing completely.
How do you know it's the same person with 2 accounts? If you're sure - report to BGA - I'm pretty sure having 2 accounts is against their rules - and must definitely be for them to be in the same tournament potentially playing against themselves.

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 16 November 2026, 00:59
by Shivaware
mrdoctor wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 23:51
Calmon70 wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 23:24 I guess this always appears as message: here as well from same tournament. Nobody abandoned manually: https://boardgamearena.com/table?table=914334103
Are you sure? https://boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=914334103

"Move 300 : 06/11/2026 07:07:05
All players (with a positive clock) chose to abandon this game."

The message is wrong. From that same log:

Move 295 : 9/27/2026 12:03:31 AM
Move 299 : 12:04:14 AM
Move 300 : 11/6/2026 12:07:05 AM


Sep 27th is a Sunday. Nov 1 is a Sunday 5 weeks (or 35 days) later. Therefore, Nov 6th is 40 days after the last move.

From https://boardgamearena.com/faq?anchor=f ... cleangames :
A turn-based table is closed automatically if no move has been made in 40 days.

Re: Tournament bug: One inactive player causes everyone to lose(win) instead of just the inactive player

Posted: 16 November 2026, 01:18
by mrdoctor
Fair enough. They should change the message that pops up in the game log then, as it makes it very confusing.