Board Game Arena

Hello, how do you know who gave us a bad reputation and never play again with this person please

Hello,

That's very simple:

• On the profile on each player, your opinion about him/her is displayed on the upper right corner.
• If this player is at the same table than you, a red thumb appears next to his/her name.

Cheers,

Can we have the list without having to go into each player's page?

Hi, unless I'm missing something, I don't see how we can find out if a player doesn't like us.
We can only check if we don't like to play with him.
It would be nice to know, when we look for a table, if somebody doesn't like us, so as to not join.
Otherwise, great new system!

Yes, I missed that too...

The info we have already is players we dont like, not the players dont like us...

Hello,

You can't know if somebody gave you a green/red thumb. It's a private information. If we make this information public, players will start to think "I won't give him a red because he's going to give me a red too" or will start to deploy some strategies like "I give you a green, you give me a green".

Cheers,

Hi, I'm sorry I don't agree with this point of view.

If somebody doesn't like to play with me, I'd like to know it so I go ahead and play on another table.
I feel ok if somebody doesn't like my play style, so I don't want to disturb a game where I'm not welcome and not knowing it.
On the other hand, if I didn't give him a red in return, then it's to advise him to give me another chance and join one of my tables if he so desires.

In addition, I'll never give a green to get a green. And if I give a red it's for some good reason, so I don't fear to get reds in return, because I'll probably not want to play again with a player I gave a red, unless he doesn't give me a red in return so I might reconsider my opinion (like above the other way).

Finally, I don't see how this information would be public, it could be seen only by the giver and the given.
Regards

It isn't completely private. If you go look at your rating immediately following a game, you can see if the player rated you. I was very confused as to how I was getting any thumbs down and started this practice. I found it has been exclusive to bad losers in the game Can't Stop.

Hello,

Okay, I created a poll on this subject.

Cheers,