Board Game Arena

That sounds interesting. I'd love to see some expansions for Carnegie.

Hi Cedrix, The +3 at the end of project tabs on side b means that the max 12 points for each donation is increased to a maximum of 15 points per donsation that you have made. Therefore, if you have taken 3 management departments to add to the original two, and you have chosen the management departme...

I didn't ask for a reason for why the third player has the action tile. I asked if it could be changed. The third player already gets to put out a free construction project and choose a department first.

I would like to propose a change to 3 player games of Carnegie. That is to either remove the action tile from the games, or that every player has one. The action tile is an advantage too much.

I agree with Jellby, the negative responses are ones which come more from a psychological basis - which is the often the norm here and somewhat human nature's reluctance to change. It does seem to me there is often a knee-jerk reaction to shoot down suggestions.

I completely disagree that the disadvantages out weigh the advantages when I have experienced the problems with two friends joining my game and playing somewhat cooperatively (especially towards the end of the game), who don't share the same IP address, join a table which automatically starts when f...

On this note, I will actively increase my green thumb giving because it is not up to your level. But, I still believe in what I initialy posted.

I predicted that most of the replies this would generate would be to tell me how frequently and easily people give green thumbs. I didn't really need to know that there was a small number of people that give green thumbs for conduct that should be a given - which is good of you guys. Well, I think y...

Sadly, this discussion board and discussion points often seem to descend into, and get stymied by, a battle of wits whereby people are seemingly trying to win arguments rather than improve player experience. [/quote] It's not unique, every time I want to start a stack of turnbased games, I would exp...

It is interesting that as soon as someone posts a suggestion, and I have read many here, lots of people rush in to rubbish/criticise it. No, it won't extend waiting times, and if it does it will be minimal. If you don't mind who joins your table, you will just accept to start the game. And yes, ther...