Search found 58 matches

by desertman
22 May 2026, 23:35
Forum: Catan
Topic: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?
Replies: 7
Views: 145

Re: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?

I didn't perceive this as a warning. Then I don't know what message you thought was being conveyed by a notification telling you that you had an abnormally high amount of red thumbs. But you are entitled to your perception. A warning has consequences, if being ignored. This notification had no cons...
by desertman
22 May 2026, 22:52
Forum: Catan
Topic: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?
Replies: 7
Views: 145

Re: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?

Meeplelowda wrote: 21 May 2026, 03:08 If by "notification" you are referring to a banner on your profile, that *is* the warning.
I didn't perceive this as a warning. It also didn't lower my Karma points.
by desertman
21 May 2026, 03:01
Forum: Catan
Topic: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?
Replies: 7
Views: 145

Re: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?

But they are still used to give a private warning visible only to the recipients if they get a high number. Do you know that for sure? Early in my career here, I received a notification that more than 10% of the players I had played with had given me a red thumb. However, there was no explanation a...
by desertman
21 May 2026, 02:49
Forum: Catan
Topic: I played one game of Catan for two hours. With 2 vs 1 Kingmakers.
Replies: 17
Views: 360

Re: I played one game of Catan for two hours. With 2 vs 1 Kingmakers.

Silene wrote: 21 May 2026, 02:25 did you try to get those comments deleted? if i were you, i would contact support and copy all those annoying texts into the support form and ask for them to get deleted.
Yes. At least worth a try.
by desertman
21 May 2026, 02:03
Forum: Catan
Topic: I played one game of Catan for two hours. With 2 vs 1 Kingmakers.
Replies: 17
Views: 360

Re: I played one game of Catan for two hours. With 2 vs 1 Kingmakers.

daranub wrote: 18 May 2026, 10:15 Even though he was the one at fault, he came into my activity log and plastered every record with false comments.
I had no idea that it is possible to make comments in other player's activity log. Is there a known reason why this is so?
by desertman
21 May 2026, 01:52
Forum: Catan
Topic: What are the "thumbs down" options good for?
Replies: 7
Views: 145

What are the "thumbs down" options good for?

When I give someone a thumbs down and click on the option 'Everyone should know about this,' I can select a reason for why I think everyone should know about it. See attachment. I sometimes give someone a thumbs down when they quit a game deliberately because they are angry that it is not going thei...
by desertman
22 April 2026, 18:08
Forum: Catan
Topic: Unable to find a table to play
Replies: 2
Views: 129

Re: Unable to find a table to play

... it has been 4 days and as soon as I want to join a table, it says closed even though space is available You played Catan 3 days ago. Something is wrong here. Apart from that I'm sure that your bad reputation (36%) after just playing 5 games altogether since you joined Bord Game Arena has someth...
by desertman
11 April 2026, 19:55
Forum: Catan
Topic: Can I reverse all red thumbs without remembering the names?
Replies: 3
Views: 135

Re: Can I reverse all red thumbs without remembering the names?

Thank you. That works very well to identify red thumbed players, but then they have to be "un-thumbed" one by one.
by desertman
11 April 2026, 04:38
Forum: Catan
Topic: Can I reverse all red thumbs without remembering the names?
Replies: 3
Views: 135

Can I reverse all red thumbs without remembering the names?

Can I reverse all red thumbs that I have given without remembering the names of these players?

Is there somewhere in my account a list of all players that I gave a red thumb?

I'm just in a forgiving mood!
by desertman
06 January 2026, 21:44
Forum: Catan
Topic: Friendly robber ruining Catan
Replies: 31
Views: 1512

Re: Friendly robber ruining Catan

... since the new season has adopted the friendly robber rule, the game play has declined steadily. One simple solution is to avoid tables with the Friendly Robber option activated. Even better, become a paying member and open your own tables without the Friendly Robber option. My tables don't have...

Go to advanced search