Tips on gamehelp's wiki page

[Romain672]

Hi world.
Recently I find two games where the gamehelp and the tips page were mixed.
What do you think of those?
Do you think you should really separate them and not allow any tips on the gamehelp page?
Do you think bga should merge those page? (I don't think so)

If I take the example of Hanabi, it look like there was two differents work about tips (=conventions) on the game.
https://en.doc.boardgamearena.com/Gamehelphanabi
https://en.doc.boardgamearena.com/Tips_hanabi

https://en.doc.boardgamearena.com/index ... on=history

[Silene]

Not sure if the Gamehelphanabi should be recommended. There's an edit war going on there. I tried engaging once with a note I made that "some players disagree with the last statement" which got very soon changed into "some weaker players disagree". Then I gave up. I see someone is trying again, but I think the self-called hanabi grand master will stay dominant in presenting his opinions as generally agreed-upon way of playing.

Someone should really devide those different approaches into 2 sections where both factions can write their ideas without a general advice to follow one way or the other.
But until someone finds the energy to do that, I do not think that it should be merged with anything else.

EDIT: ok i tried again to sort that out and separate the ideas into sub-sections. Hopefully that can end the edit-war. However it's probably in the wrong place - but apparently it wasn't possible to remove the disputed convention-ideas, so I think at least there should be both approaches to see.