Arena: Why 5 levels?

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
User avatar
Wiking44
Posts: 142
Joined: 10 June 2022, 14:07

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by Wiking44 »

Vandaley wrote: 03 February 2023, 03:38
Randwulf wrote: 02 February 2023, 04:57 Ok…. I am at platinum level #7 I need 3 more to make elite? I have won my last 6 matches and not moved up? What gives?
My ELO has gone up. But my plat level stays the same. But heaven forbid I lose a match… my plat level would drop like a rock like it did last time I made it to lvl 7 or 8. So how is the advancement calculated ? I stomp someone? No points just ELO. I barely win by the skin of my teeth and no points but ELO. I barely lose !!! I drop like a rock on a heavy grav world.

Please explain?
You are matching against players that are over 2 levels under you. You cannot gain when the difference is that big.
Then we should not be matched against players that are 2 levels below us...
A win should give you some Arena points no matter what the level IMHO
User avatar
Tisaac
Posts: 2736
Joined: 26 August 2014, 21:28

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by Tisaac »

Wiking44 wrote: 03 February 2023, 05:31
Vandaley wrote: 03 February 2023, 03:38
Randwulf wrote: 02 February 2023, 04:57 Ok…. I am at platinum level #7 I need 3 more to make elite? I have won my last 6 matches and not moved up? What gives?
My ELO has gone up. But my plat level stays the same. But heaven forbid I lose a match… my plat level would drop like a rock like it did last time I made it to lvl 7 or 8. So how is the advancement calculated ? I stomp someone? No points just ELO. I barely win by the skin of my teeth and no points but ELO. I barely lose !!! I drop like a rock on a heavy grav world.

Please explain?
You are matching against players that are over 2 levels under you. You cannot gain when the difference is that big.
Then we should not be matched against players that are 2 levels below us...
A win should give you some Arena points no matter what the level IMHO
It does, but people are confusing arena points with leagues. The league is just some fancy addition, the only things that maters once you reach elite is the arena points that are hidden until then. Thèse points works exactly like ELO so you will always win points if you win.
User avatar
Wiking44
Posts: 142
Joined: 10 June 2022, 14:07

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by Wiking44 »

Tisaac wrote: 03 February 2023, 07:12
Wiking44 wrote: 03 February 2023, 05:31
Vandaley wrote: 03 February 2023, 03:38

You are matching against players that are over 2 levels under you. You cannot gain when the difference is that big.
Then we should not be matched against players that are 2 levels below us...
A win should give you some Arena points no matter what the level IMHO
It does, but people are confusing arena points with leagues. The league is just some fancy addition, the only things that maters once you reach elite is the arena points that are hidden until then. Thèse points works exactly like ELO so you will always win points if you win.
OK so we are saying that a win should give us at least 1 league point or we should not be matched vs a player that is 2 levels below us if that's possible
User avatar
ripted pizzaz
Posts: 28
Joined: 02 February 2017, 06:20

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by ripted pizzaz »

If we only had 4 levels, you'd always win a league point. Right now if you're Platinum and beat Bronze, you get zero. But if there was no Platinum, just Gold then Elite, you'd always win at least one point. Other games have this arrangement.
User avatar
Wiking44
Posts: 142
Joined: 10 June 2022, 14:07

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by Wiking44 »

ripted pizzaz wrote: 03 February 2023, 17:24 If we only had 4 levels, you'd always win a league point. Right now if you're Platinum and beat Bronze, you get zero. But if there was no Platinum, just Gold then Elite, you'd always win at least one point. Other games have this arrangement.
Well said!
User avatar
MagnusNygaard
Posts: 181
Joined: 16 October 2022, 12:16

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by MagnusNygaard »

ripted pizzaz wrote: 03 February 2023, 17:24 If we only had 4 levels, you'd always win a league point. Right now if you're Platinum and beat Bronze, you get zero. But if there was no Platinum, just Gold then Elite, you'd always win at least one point. Other games have this arrangement.
+1 ... is it possible to make this a suggestion for M44? Or is it something that BGA decides?
User avatar
Tisaac
Posts: 2736
Joined: 26 August 2014, 21:28

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by Tisaac »

MagnusNygaard wrote: 04 February 2023, 17:35
ripted pizzaz wrote: 03 February 2023, 17:24 If we only had 4 levels, you'd always win a league point. Right now if you're Platinum and beat Bronze, you get zero. But if there was no Platinum, just Gold then Elite, you'd always win at least one point. Other games have this arrangement.
+1 ... is it possible to make this a suggestion for M44? Or is it something that BGA decides?
We have no control on that. It's made 100% automatically by bga.
User avatar
harmonius
Posts: 49
Joined: 22 August 2011, 09:31

Re: Arena: Why 5 levels?

Post by harmonius »

You also have the possibility to set what level difference you agree to play against (sorry for french)

Image
Post Reply

Return to “Memoir 44”