Field point error

[Paikea]

Hello,
I have just finished a game of Carcassonne, where an error showed up which I saw quite many times now, and today I had some time to report it here.
Both players have 1 pawn on that specific field, still red was shown to score the 6 points. Even when replaying the scoring, there was no doubt about that it went that way. The game number is 526673585.
I really still do hope that I missed something, but there are definitely no other pawns used, and the two involved are of the same strength.

[euklid314]

I see 2 red+1 blue in the large field on the left (21 pts).

I see 1 red in the field on the bottom right for 9 pts.

Then two mini fields for blue and one for red for 3 pts each. Finally a shared field (top right for 6 points each).

Thus the scoring is correct.

[euklid314]

Hello,
I have just finished a game of Carcassonne, where an error showed up which I saw quite many times now, and today I had some time to report it here.
Both players have 1 pawn on that specific field, still red was shown to score the 6 points. Even when replaying the scoring, there was no doubt about that it went that way. The game number is 526673585.
I really still do hope that I missed something, but there are definitely no other pawns used, and the two involved are of the same strength.

Upon rereading your post I realize that you specifically talk about the field in the top right where red and blue share majority. Thus red got 6 points and blue got 6 points.

Did you miss that you also got 6 points or is there some misunderstanding of the rules?

In any case the fields were scored correctly in your game...

[Meeplelowda]

Hello,
I have just finished a game of Carcassonne, where an error showed up which I saw quite many times now, and today I had some time to report it here.
Both players have 1 pawn on that specific field, still red was shown to score the 6 points. Even when replaying the scoring, there was no doubt about that it went that way. The game number is 526673585.
I really still do hope that I missed something, but there are definitely no other pawns used, and the two involved are of the same strength.

Upon rereading your post I realize that you specifically talk about the field in the top right where red and blue share majority. Thus red got 6 points and blue got 6 points.

Did you miss that you also got 6 points or is there some misunderstanding of the rules?

In any case the fields were scored correctly in your game...

Maybe that part of the game log would help illustrate this point:

andylapus scores 6 points with a majority of 1 farmer(s)
Paikea scores 6 points with a majority of 1 farmer(s)