Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Post Reply
User avatar
than_tham_tho_map
Posts: 5
Joined: 21 July 2020, 11:59

Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by than_tham_tho_map »

At the end of each round, it would be very convenient if the 2 cards discarded by your opponent are revealed. Sometimes, I have to really watched the replay to see what are the cards (but only after the game ended so that I can choose to view from the other side).
User avatar
ufm
Posts: 2039
Joined: 06 January 2017, 08:38

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by ufm »

If you want to check private information, do it in replay.
User avatar
than_tham_tho_map
Posts: 5
Joined: 21 July 2020, 11:59

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by than_tham_tho_map »

ufm wrote: 29 July 2023, 11:46 If you want to check private information, do it in replay.
I mean to reveal the discarded cards at the end of the round
User avatar
lordofwatersheep
Posts: 22
Joined: 21 May 2021, 19:01

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by lordofwatersheep »

than_tham_tho_map wrote: 29 July 2023, 11:02 At the end of each round, it would be very convenient if the 2 cards discarded by your opponent are revealed. Sometimes, I have to really watched the replay to see what are the cards (but only after the game ended so that I can choose to view from the other side).
Fully agreed, at that point it's no longer private info. Would be nice to reveal the one unused card too, though that can be inferred
User avatar
balak90st
Posts: 4
Joined: 20 November 2023, 21:00

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by balak90st »

Im agree, i played this game in other sites and at the end of each round u can choose the option to see the discarted cards also there is a count of rounds. My record is 7 rounds in a game.
User avatar
erisalke
Posts: 5
Joined: 01 October 2024, 23:44

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by erisalke »

I disagree. This information should remain hidden at all times. Knowing which card were removed by the opponent gives a huge insight into their strategy and play style. The rules at no point say those cards should be revealed either.
User avatar
NickChemE
Posts: 2
Joined: 02 December 2023, 22:44

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by NickChemE »

erisalke wrote: 18 December 2024, 03:26 I disagree. This information should remain hidden at all times. Knowing which card were removed by the opponent gives a huge insight into their strategy and play style. The rules at no point say those cards should be revealed either.
While I agree with the sentiment, if it can be accessed (which it can be via replay from the opponents perspective), then why make it more difficult to get there.
User avatar
ufm
Posts: 2039
Joined: 06 January 2017, 08:38

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by ufm »

NickChemE wrote: 04 January 2025, 21:36 While I agree with the sentiment, if it can be accessed (which it can be via replay from the opponents perspective), then why make it more difficult to get there.
Because you can't do so during the game. The replay is available after finishing the game.
JohnnyCyclops
Posts: 282
Joined: 05 July 2023, 22:06

Re: Suggestion: revealed opponent Trade-off cards at the end of the round

Post by JohnnyCyclops »

Agree it’s hidden information during game play. As is the 21st card returned to the box.

I suppose two players might agree to look at that 21st card between rounds when reshuffling and to also look at the four cards discarded during game play. But I don’t think it tells a whole lot or informs the next round. And, if it DID inform the next round then it’s better kept hidden.

That said, between rounds it’s possible for me to deduce my opponent’s two discards and the 21st card, from the 16 cards that were played plus my own two discards. That’s sufficient for my purposes.
Post Reply

Return to “Hanamikoji”