How did they win?

[dthowe]

Table 617480571

Player had 14 at beginning of their turn. Rolls 1-1-1-1-1-Heart. Player has Gourmet card in play stating to add 2 points in addition to the regular effects if they roll 1-1-1 or better.

I count 3pts for the actual roll plus 2 points for Gourmet.

Game log shows 3pts and 2pts gained but score goes to 20 and game ends.

I see of no way the other point was gained.

[Meeplelowda]

Player had 14 at beginning of their turn. Rolls 1-1-1-1-1-Heart. Player has Gourmet card in play stating to add 2 points in addition to the regular effects if they roll 1-1-1 or better.

I count 3pts for the actual roll plus 2 points for Gourmet.

Game log shows 3pts and 2pts gained but score goes to 20 and game ends.

I see of no way the other point was gained.

This is all accurate, except the score. They had 16 points before the first roll on their final turn.
https://imgur.com/a/axXjwjz

[FluffyWuffy1]

The bug looks to be on the previous turn, where Gigazaur moved from 10 to 16 after rolling four 1s. This should score 2, plus 2 for Gourmet.

Even although it doesn't make sense, I think this might be a bug with Icy Reflection - I've seen some very odd stuff happen with that card in specific scenarios. Anyway, you should report the bug on the Bugs page, see if it can be fixed.

[Meeplelowda]

The bug looks to be on the previous turn, where Gigazaur moved from 10 to 16 after rolling four 1s. This should score 2, plus 2 for Gourmet.

Even although it doesn't make sense, I think this might be a bug with Icy Reflection - I've seen some very odd stuff happen with that card in specific scenarios. Anyway, you should report the bug on the Bugs page, see if it can be fixed.

They never went from 10 to 16. They went from 9 to 12 with the rolls commencing at Move 136:

Move 136 :6:11:25 PM
Dendarii rolls dice [dice1][dice1][dice3][diceHeart][diceHeart][diceSmash]
Move 137 :6:11:39 PM
Dendarii keeps [dice1][dice1][diceHeart][diceHeart] and rerolls dice [dice2][dice3]
Move 138 :6:11:42 PM
Dendarii keeps [dice1][dice1][diceHeart][diceHeart] and rerolls dice [diceHeart][diceSmash]
Move 140 :6:11:52 PM
Dendarii plays 3058
Dendarii uses 3058 and rolled [diceSmash] to [dice1]
Move 141 :6:11:57 PM
Dendarii resolves dice [dice1][dice1][dice1][diceHeart][diceHeart][diceHeart]
Dendarii gains 1[Star] with [dice1] dice
Dendarii gains 2 [Star] with 19
Dendarii gains 3 [Heart]

Then from 12 to 16 with the rolls commencing at Move 173:

Move 173 :6:15:38 PM
Dendarii rolls dice [dice1][dice1][dice2][dice2][diceSmash][diceSmash]
Move 174 :6:15:53 PM
Dendarii keeps [dice1][dice1] and rerolls dice [dice2][diceHeart][diceSmash][diceSmash]
Move 175 :6:15:57 PM
Dendarii keeps [dice1][dice1][diceHeart] and rerolls dice [dice1][dice3][dice3]
Move 177 :6:16:06 PM
Dendarii uses 3058 and rolled [dice3] to [dice1]
Move 178 :6:16:10 PM
Dendarii resolves dice [dice1][dice1][dice1][dice1][dice3][diceHeart]
Dendarii gains 2[Star] with [dice1] dice
Dendarii gains 2 [Star] with 19
Dendarii gains 1 [Heart]

[FluffyWuffy1]

Table 617480571

Player had 14 at beginning of their turn. Rolls 1-1-1-1-1-Heart. Player has Gourmet card in play stating to add 2 points in addition to the regular effects if they roll 1-1-1 or better.

I count 3pts for the actual roll plus 2 points for Gourmet.

Game log shows 3pts and 2pts gained but score goes to 20 and game ends.

I see of no way the other point was gained.

Seems after all that it's a bug with the replayer. I am able to recreate the scenario you described, with 14 at the beginning of the final turn. I can also recreate the one where the 2nd last turn gives 6. And sometimes it works without any bugs. But the underlying maths all seems correct, so no actual bug with the gameplay.

[Meeplelowda]

Seems after all that it's a bug with the replayer. I am able to recreate the scenario you described, with 14 at the beginning of the final turn. I can also recreate the one where the 2nd last turn gives 6. And sometimes it works without any bugs. But the underlying maths all seems correct, so no actual bug with the gameplay.

The screenshot I took and linked to showing the turn starting at 16 is also from the replayer. So if there is a bug, it's intermittent.

One difference may be that I used the "Go to specific move (fast)" feature, so no graphics are rendered until it gets to that move. So maybe it's avoiding a display error that crops up if you use the slow version of going to the move. If you also used the fast version, then it's definitely a bug in the replayer showing different things.