Throwing it out there

[NocturnalMako84]

How about a vote to have the mods reset red thumbs? Let's be honest with ourselves, it's made game making far too long half the time and we don't even recall why we red thumbed someone in the first place it's been so long since we did.

[Paddles]

No thanks. Whenever I've given a red thumb, there's been a reason for why I would rather wait/not play a game than play against that person. It's for me to review whether my reasons have changed and go back to change the thumbs, not for the site to arbitrarily decide that for me.

Same goes if someone has red thumbed me. This site is supposed to be fun; if someone decides that playing against me is not enjoyable for whatever reason then it's not for BGA to unilaterally declare their reason as no longer valid.

[NocturnalMako84]

Fair enough. Just floating an idea. Humor me though. What is a red thumbable offense and when, if ever, would you change your position? You're not going to be playing with said player. One day you might just decide to give them another chance?