Season 21 results (based on ~1,000 games)
This distribution is a clear meta-indicator for Fistful of Cards. Historically, the Outlaws’ winrate share was around 60–61% (from AVtactics data for the 6 players seasons), but now it’s closer to 64% — that’s a significant tilt in favor of the Outlaws.
Why? One reason is the new Roulette event — it always starts with the Sheriff, forcing him to take the first risk. It’s basically an extra squeeze on the strongest Sheriff picks — especially Bart Cassidy. Bart either has to win before the final event or risk dying in a tight 1v1. His ability can even backfire in the last event. So the expansion indirectly nerfs strong Sheriff plays and shifts the power toward aggressive Outlaw teams.

As for me, my personal winrate this season ended up at 49.3% — a bit higher than my lifetime clean average of around 46%. That’s clean, because I don’t count Abandoned Games — and you shouldn’t either.

Here’s why: abandoned games artificially inflate winrates by about 4% on average. I’ve reviewed a ton of player profiles, and roughly 10% of all games are abandoned. Most of these add extra “ghost wins” that push up your numbers for free. So if you’re checking your own profile — don’t just divide your total wins by your total games and call it good. Subtract those ~4% to get your real winrate.
Around mid-season, I was holding 52.5% ~ 500 games — so distance does flatten the curve. Maybe I’d hit another streak later, maybe not — but even so, the fact I finished this season above my baseline shows the new expansion really gives strong players more ways to push an edge.
A few other good players’ stats back this up:
Goodness Freedom: 500 games, 50.2% clean winrate
kuzestanx: ~300 games, 52% clean winrate (edit)
If the new events were pure coin flips, we wouldn’t see any consistent edge. Like I said: if you play rock-paper-scissors with a drunk guy outside your building — he’s got the same odds as a world champ. Pure luck equalizes everyone. So the fact we can still push above 50% proves the game’s added more strategy, not more raw RNG.
Fistful of Cards boosted Outlaws, gave better players more ways to win, and proved once again that strategy beats raw luck

