The Best of Both Worlds: What BGA does better?

[BalGAmor]

We love cardboard, but BGA makes some things easier, and lighter! Is it the automated scoring or the 24/7 matchmaking you appreciate most? Tell us about your favorite digital perk.

[Shivaware]

I enjoy the fact that I can play a game without having to teach players how to play and having to watch their moves carefully to make sure they aren't making rules errors.

[tbhp]

I think even from a visual perspective I like how games can look on BGA. I'm very much a screen person, so while having the physical game in front of you and in your hands is a great feeling too, I also love the atmosphere of playing a game virtually. They are two different and complementary ways of experiencing a game.

Another thing is the ability to play several games at once, which doesn't have an equivalent in real life. Some may say it's detrimental because it breaks the continuous flow of a game. It's certainly different from the way games and art in general are traditionally meant to be experienced, but it offers us new kinds of experiences, like the feeling you are in an arena and you have to fight back your opponents on all fronts.

The ability to play turn based also allows us to think a lot more deeply about the strategies and the possibilities than we probably would when playing in real life with a group of people. So, the site gives every game a competitive scene and a venue where they can be played at the highest level, which until then only a few specific games like Chess were able to enjoy.

[Paddles]

Another thing is the ability to play several games at once, which doesn't have an equivalent in real life.

Can be done, if you have enough people, physical sets and table space. Eminently possible at a gaming convention, but also possible at a private gaming day/night if you know enough players, have enough sets and the game tempo/mechanics supports multi-gaming without games being blocked by someone at the other table (either low-interaction, or a house rule to manage it).

Many moons ago I organised a session of three simultaneous games of Axis and Allies (excuse: this was in the days before Catan and many other eurogames had been invented) and 10 people. House rule to keep it moving: if you had to move on two different tables, one of your allies on a table could manage your defence on a table for you.

[Gooorn]

Both the automated scoring and the 24/7 matchmaking is digital benefit, and the cat/dog can't made a mess of the board game.

[tbhp]

Both the automated scoring and the 24/7 matchmaking is digital benefit, and the cat/dog can't made a mess of the board game.

Not just cat and dog, but anything that could physically affect a board, plus most of the ways someone could cheat or unintentionally make an illegal move become impossible on a digital system.

On the flip side, bugs can exist (and if they do, you are generally stuck with them), but fortunately they are very rare in most games.

[Cos-]

It's very useful to learn a game here, because the software prevents you from doing things the rules don't allow, and guides you to see what is possible. Sometimes when people learn new games from the physical box, they misunderstand some of the rules or scoring, and nobody notices until some time in the future when they play with people who learned at a different time and place, and people realize they have different understandings of how the game works and have to sort it out.

[katmk]

No set-up means more time playing.

[RicardoRix]

No setup.
Rules come for free.
And main thing is just being able to play such varied games in different competitive formats. In Real-Life is just a win to get enough people with enough time and to agree on a game to play. BGA has everything compared to that.
The one negative is real-life games are just so much more immersive and provide much more memorable experiences.

[BananaHarambe]

The ability to play a game "slowly" in turn-based at my own pace is practical on BGA, not practical for irl board gaming. This, in addition to the automated setup and rules handling makes playing board games regularly practical for a wide variety of busy people.

This also fixes some of the matchmaking problems real time games have with requiring all players online and looking for the game at the same time. The option for Turn based likely reduces real time player count by a bit, but allows a larger variety of games to remain viable to play on BGA. With player dilution with all the new games releasing this is more important now than ever.