How does Arena voting timing work?

Discussions about BGA (all languages)
Forum rules
Warning: challenging a moderation in Forum = 10 days ban
More info & details about how to challenge a moderation: viewtopic.php?p=119756
Post Reply
User avatar
ResonanceSM
Posts: 47
Joined: 27 September 2021, 03:26

How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by ResonanceSM »

So, 7 days ago, we got a message in Arena saying:
Season 25 will end in 2 weeks' time! Don't forget to suggest and vote for your favorite Arena formats before the final voting starts in 1 week!
Remember that the final voting is between the current format and the most highly voted suggestion.
Today we get a message saying:
With your votes, you decided as Gurus to keep the current Arena format for next season. Thank you!
Is it just that, not enough votes for suggestions so there was no final voting? (None of the other options were positive.). I guess I misunderstood the "Remember" part.
User avatar
tarongot
Posts: 150
Joined: 10 March 2013, 20:30

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by tarongot »

ResonanceSM wrote: 08 July 2026, 14:48 So, 7 days ago, we got a message in Arena saying:
Season 25 will end in 2 weeks' time! Don't forget to suggest and vote for your favorite Arena formats before the final voting starts in 1 week!
Remember that the final voting is between the current format and the most highly voted suggestion.
Today we get a message saying:
With your votes, you decided as Gurus to keep the current Arena format for next season. Thank you!
Is it just that, not enough votes for suggestions so there was no final voting? (None of the other options were positive.). I guess I misunderstood the "Remember" part.
Arena vote has 2 phases:

1. Choose proposition with most votes that goes to next phase.
2. Proposition chosen in phase 1 compete with current arena season setting in final vote on settings for next arena season.

Looks like in your case current settings won in phase 1 so in this game settings for next season are decided already.
FrankJones
Posts: 2451
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by FrankJones »

Yes, but the OP is right. This makes no sense. I received the same two messages. "Final voting begins in one week", and then, before any final voting (which usually remains open until the end of the season), "With your votes, you have decided ...."

What happened to the actual final voting? I never had a chance to vote.

In the other game for which I am a guru, the final voting is still open (as it should be, since the final voting just began.)

Maybe for the first game, nobody made any format change suggestions, and so "keep the same" won by default without the need for a final vote?
User avatar
tbhp
Posts: 722
Joined: 16 April 2025, 00:35

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by tbhp »

Where do people receive those messages? I received nothing and only found out I was a guru a few days ago when coincidentally checking the community page, which I usually never use.
FrankJones wrote: 08 July 2026, 17:01 Maybe for the first game, nobody made any format change suggestions, and so "keep the same" won by default without the need for a final vote?
Seems to be it. The voting has definitely been open for me since I found the page. Probably no one created a suggestion or voted for it in the game you're talking about. But you still should have been able to vote for the default "keep the current format" option.
User avatar
ResonanceSM
Posts: 47
Joined: 27 September 2021, 03:26

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by ResonanceSM »

tbhp wrote: 08 July 2026, 17:09 Where do people receive those messages? I received nothing and only found out I was a guru a few days ago when coincidentally checking the community page, which I usually never use.
My profile picture was blinking red and I had a notification that there was a message on the guru page.

Maybe you became a guru after the message?
Ceaseless
Posts: 1310
Joined: 12 November 2022, 17:06

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by Ceaseless »

ResonanceSM wrote: 08 July 2026, 14:48 So, 7 days ago, we got a message in Arena saying:
Season 25 will end in 2 weeks' time! Don't forget to suggest and vote for your favorite Arena formats before the final voting starts in 1 week!
Remember that the final voting is between the current format and the most highly voted suggestion.
Today we get a message saying:
With your votes, you decided as Gurus to keep the current Arena format for next season. Thank you!
Is it just that, not enough votes for suggestions so there was no final voting? (None of the other options were positive.). I guess I misunderstood the "Remember" part.
Who would be the opposition, if none of the options could even get more than 0 votes?
FrankJones wrote: 08 July 2026, 17:01 Yes, but the OP is right. This makes no sense. I received the same two messages. "Final voting begins in one week", and then, before any final voting (which usually remains open until the end of the season), "With your votes, you have decided ...."

What happened to the actual final voting? I never had a chance to vote.

In the other game for which I am a guru, the final voting is still open (as it should be, since the final voting just began.)

Maybe for the first game, nobody made any format change suggestions, and so "keep the same" won by default without the need for a final vote?
I'm going with this being a factor.
ResonanceSM wrote: 08 July 2026, 14:48 None of the other options were positive
User avatar
tbhp
Posts: 722
Joined: 16 April 2025, 00:35

Re: How does Arena voting timing work?

Post by tbhp »

ResonanceSM wrote: 08 July 2026, 18:35
tbhp wrote: 08 July 2026, 17:09 Where do people receive those messages? I received nothing and only found out I was a guru a few days ago when coincidentally checking the community page, which I usually never use.
My profile picture was blinking red and I had a notification that there was a message on the guru page.

Maybe you became a guru after the message?
I never got anything like that in my notifications.

Everyone becomes a guru at the same time, I think.
Post Reply

Return to “Discussions”