dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
User avatar
Silene
Posts: 1031
Joined: 23 October 2013, 17:50

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Silene »

You don't need to have played a game a lot to spot a pattern. The pattern of when there's luck involved there will definitely be people around who complain about the randomness being flawed. It can be observed in all the luck-driven-popular-game forums. So either it is some big conspriracy that put a ton of effort into replacing a
(a) simple random number call
with a
(b) complex system of evaluation game status, evaluating people at the table, tweaking the numbers in a way that is not too obvious but only visible to some very special observant people, hiding the code, bribing all the volunteer and/or professional developers etc. And to what end? To favor one chosen player in the game. Why this one? To gain what? Suspicions on which groups of players are usually favoured are all over the place. After all this is user vs. user and not user vs. the bank.

Either that or people have trouble understanding that randomness naturally produces weird patterns without any bias at work.

It doesn't stop at the borders of BGA. So if you say it is something specifically happening on BGA I can tell you - it is and was the same on other platforms. I used to play a lot on another platform which made Catan available for online play ~30 years ago (and it still is available there). And guess what? In the same manner people have posted on the forum there that they are sure something spooky is going around with the RNG in Catan. That site even had an on-the-fly-statistics of all the dice-rolls available. Not sure if that made it better or worse...

So if you have "spotted" it on BGA but not on other platforms... maybe you are only among the chosen ones who can see it here and on other platforms others were chosen... or maybe give the thought a try that you might have spotted some indeed strange results (that can happen naturally on unbiased RNG) and since then spiralled into confirmation-biased perception. Occasionaly run into weird results again (which again naturally happens on unbiased RNG) and perceive them very strongly and remember for long while unspectacular results quickly fade from your memory.
Check out the Allround-League: https://boardgamearena.com/group?id=7870115 --> a league where you have matches of random games vs. other players in your group. Season 10 is running Oct. '26 - Feb. '27
Asterix9999
Posts: 1
Joined: 14 December 2024, 16:25

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Asterix9999 »

the dice algorithm is always running for the player with the highest score, always. if he builds at 2 or 12, you can bet, the 2 and 12 is coming more than 6 or 8. I have been playing Catan for years, but now it is not fun anymore. the winner is clear from beginning
User avatar
Gaudi
Posts: 2
Joined: 05 August 2015, 02:26

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Gaudi »

Asterix9999 wrote: ↑13 November 2026, 15:23 the dice algorithm is always running for the player with the highest score, always. if he builds at 2 or 12, you can bet, the 2 and 12 is coming more than 6 or 8. I have been playing Catan for years, but now it is not fun anymore. the winner is clear from beginning
Are you sure you know what "always" means?
User avatar
Suoivax
Posts: 397
Joined: 13 April 2022, 00:27

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Suoivax »

Asterix9999 wrote: ↑13 November 2026, 15:23 the dice algorithm is always running for the player with the highest score, always. if he builds at 2 or 12, you can bet, the 2 and 12 is coming more than 6 or 8. I have been playing Catan for years, but now it is not fun anymore. the winner is clear from beginning
Pics or it didn't happen.
aloof-rabbit
Posts: 30
Joined: 13 August 2025, 13:27

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by aloof-rabbit »

Just for shits and giggles... i just played a game where if you exclude the two times that 7 rolled during 'easy start' (which are re-rolled so have no bearing on the game), the 7 only rolled one other time the entire game.
Knibbeltje
Posts: 6
Joined: 07 September 2026, 22:05

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Knibbeltje »

Paddles wrote: ↑10 November 2026, 13:26
Coleus1 wrote: ↑10 November 2026, 10:04 Users who are loud to defend the "random" BGA Catan dice do not even play the game :lol: the game is also much more than dice rolls over a number of games.
Paddles wrote: ↑06 November 2026, 12:59 So how can you tell that it really was biased towards a player, rather than the simpler hypothesis that one of the players happened to be lucky in the first few rounds with a fair random number generator?
By playing the game a lot both on BGA, other sites and real life and noticing how easily one can spot the favored player after first few rolls on BGA Catan? When was the last time you played BGA Catan?
You didn't actually answer the question of how you can differentiate between a player being favoured vs. a player being lucky in the early rolls i.e. what makes this bias rather than luck - all you did was repeat your original assertion that you can. If your definition of "favoured player" is the post hoc observation that a player was lucky on the early rolls therefore they must have been favoured by a biased algorithm then you need to read and understand about logical fallacies, specifically "affirming the consequent".

I will admit I don't play Catan here as much as you do, but if you'd checked my profile you could see exactly how many games I'd played here and how recently (142, and September). You could also see my history of other games that include dice or similar random selections, including other games where people make the same claims about bias without any evidence, let alone statistical rigour.

The integrity of the underlying RNG used in BGA has been validated by numerous mathematically skilled people and teams; the specific BGA code that uses that RNG for Catan can be inspected by anyone who joins the BGA development program, so any actual coded bias should be relatively easy to prove (and yet, no one has yet, despite numerous claims). But your claim is, so far, an unprovable/unfalsifiable "I know it when I see it". Even if you can't prove it, I'd be happy to see something that could at least be tested experimentally.
I totally accept that for an answer. I didn't know that integrity had been validated and for the record: I never claimed any sort of bias, it's just that random generated by a computer always feels differtent from real life. A little bit of googling tells me there's different types of RNG's. Which one does BGA use?
Knibbeltje
Posts: 6
Joined: 07 September 2026, 22:05

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Knibbeltje »

...Although I still feel that making the deck out of one deck instead of two cut in half would be better. Now there can be games where there are no 6's or 8's in a deck. Why not offer both variants on BGA?
Post Reply

Return to “Catan”