Players conceding/resigning the game early

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/#!bugs
User avatar
andi330
Posts: 6
Joined: 27 January 2023, 06:44

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by andi330 »

Honestly, I give thumbs down to people who concede games, especially if I look at their history and see that they do it a lot. There are some games, like chess, where it is customary and acceptable to resign if it is clear you are going to lose, but most games aren't like that and it smacks of being a sore loser imo. That same person wouldn't quit if they were playing in person. I just had someone do it, and when I looked at their game history, it is apparent that they concede instead playing out their games whenever they think they are going to lose. Thankfully, I've only ever had it happen twice so it is clearly a minority of people who do it.
User avatar
RandomUN
Posts: 34
Joined: 13 February 2021, 06:32

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by RandomUN »

andi330 wrote: ↑12 November 2026, 10:48 Honestly, I give thumbs down to people who concede games, especially if I look at their history and see that they do it a lot. There are some games, like chess, where it is customary and acceptable to resign if it is clear you are going to lose, but most games aren't like that and it smacks of being a sore loser imo. That same person wouldn't quit if they were playing in person. I just had someone do it, and when I looked at their game history, it is apparent that they concede instead playing out their games whenever they think they are going to lose. Thankfully, I've only ever had it happen twice so it is clearly a minority of people who do it.
This argument gets revived again. The two most recent threads in this game deal with the same thing.

You're welcome to give anyone you like a red thumb for any reason you see fit. You'll have fewer people to match with for games in any game you play that the other person also plays, and so will they, increasing the overall time it takes to find a game across the platform, but sure, do what you like. They are your red thumbs to give. It is a part of the site, just like conceding is a part of the platform that people use.

I am not, myself, someone who regularly concedes. But in my opinion, this is exactly the sort of game where it is acceptable. There comes a point where a player mathematically cannot win. They've given you the win you earned, more time to play another game, and themselves the ability to move on to another game. There's absolutely no harm being done to you. They've admitted defeat when it became evident. Forcing a player to sit through the remainder of the game so you can see just how badly you beat them is being a sore winner. They CONCEDED. They said "you win, good game."

If you're playing to see who wins or loses, congratulations, you won. If you're playing for a high score, there's a solo option that doesn't require waiting on your opponent or forcing your opponent to sit through their losing game with you.

There is such a thing as a sore winner. Coming to the forums, posting about how you give other people red thumbs for giving you a win in an online game because you didn't get to win in the way you wanted is about as clear an example of that as it gets.
User avatar
Semprini72
Posts: 34
Joined: 04 May 2026, 03:03

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by Semprini72 »

andi330 wrote: ↑12 November 2026, 10:48 Honestly, I give thumbs down to people who concede games
Now THAT is poor sportsmanship and worthy of being flagged for inappropriate thumbs-down.
User avatar
andi330
Posts: 6
Joined: 27 January 2023, 06:44

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by andi330 »

Yeah, I give thumbs down for just me, not for the whole community. Because I don't want to play with that person again. And that's a the whole purpose of the thumbs down for only me. I looked at their history, and they concede every game they think they aren't going to win if they get to the 50% mark. It's clear they aren't interested in playing games to completion if they think they aren't going to win. In my case, I probably would have won, but it certainly wasn't guaranteed at that point. It's not about winning for me. You would see that if you looked at my game history because I lose way more often than I win, in pretty much every game I play. It's bad game etiquette to dump out because you'd rather not play to the end of a game if you can't win it. Honestly, bga should give people the option to turn off the option to concede if you are setting up a table. That way people who don't want to play with people who concede all the time won't have to.
User avatar
Semprini72
Posts: 34
Joined: 04 May 2026, 03:03

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by Semprini72 »

andi330 wrote: ↑14 November 2026, 19:59 Yeah, I give thumbs down for just me, not for the whole community. Because I don't want to play with that person again. And that's a the whole purpose of the thumbs down for only me. I looked at their history, and they concede every game they think they aren't going to win if they get to the 50% mark. It's clear they aren't interested in playing games to completion if they think they aren't going to win. In my case, I probably would have won, but it certainly wasn't guaranteed at that point. It's not about winning for me. You would see that if you looked at my game history because I lose way more often than I win, in pretty much every game I play. It's bad game etiquette to dump out because you'd rather not play to the end of a game if you can't win it. Honestly, bga should give people the option to turn off the option to concede if you are setting up a table. That way people who don't want to play with people who concede all the time won't have to.
How much you win or lose has nothing to do with it. Sure, it would be nice to have a feature to continue your card if the other player concedes, but there is nothing wrong with conceding. Don't blame your opponent for the lack of feature.

I'm not looking up your game history just to play a card of yahtzee that takes 3 freaking minutes. If someone concedes, just take your win. If it bothers you that much, play solo, or play tournaments. Tournaments are great because most of them disallow concedes because they use aggregate as a tiebreak. Round robins have tons of games going simultaneously. You're on your work break and get to play your turn on 5 different games, and someone else happens to be online and you can go back and forth. Tons of action, tons of scores and no concedes. No reason to go around thumbing people for lame reasons.
nuhanala
Posts: 6
Joined: 01 May 2025, 22:01

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by nuhanala »

I agree the conceders are really annoying, and I also red thumb everyone who does it so I'd have to deal with that less often. It's the most ingratiating when someone does it one turn away from the game being over; sometimes I will be literally clicking on that last section and get an error because the opponent has conceded a quarter of a second earlier. It's incredibly rude in those cases. It would be good to have a setting where everyone could play either games where you can or cannot concede, since clearly there are two camps on this that are never going to merge.
User avatar
Semprini72
Posts: 34
Joined: 04 May 2026, 03:03

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by Semprini72 »

It's the anti-concede crowd that is the problem. They don't understand the math and they don't understand how the game works.

Just now, I just played against a very poor player with 100 elo. He made terrible decisions, going for inside straights and getting behind on top very badly. Goes for full house right away with 2-pair and of course hits it. Then he buttlucks a yahtzee on the 3rd turn and I'm still keeping up with him, and then he buttlucks 4 5s and 4 6s late in the game to get his top. I try open-ended TWICE for large straight and can't hit it. Now I can't catch him, he's like 90 pts ahead and I had to scratch my yahtzee and large straight. I'm playing way better than he is and he's destroying me - which is normal for yahtzee but he doesn't understand this. So I concede with 2 turns to go and he says ...
Poor sports concede games
What a goof. Calls me a poor sport but he's a sore winner. That's a 100% thumbs down. Learn to play before you spout off. Players who understand how the game works usually don't care if you concede.
User avatar
RandomUN
Posts: 34
Joined: 13 February 2021, 06:32

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by RandomUN »

Semprini72 wrote: ↑16 November 2026, 15:47 It's the anti-concede crowd that is the problem. They don't understand the math and they don't understand how the game works.

Just now, I just played against a very poor player with 100 elo. He made terrible decisions, going for inside straights and getting behind on top very badly. Goes for full house right away with 2-pair and of course hits it. Then he buttlucks a yahtzee on the 3rd turn and I'm still keeping up with him, and then he buttlucks 4 5s and 4 6s late in the game to get his top. I try open-ended TWICE for large straight and can't hit it. Now I can't catch him, he's like 90 pts ahead and I had to scratch my yahtzee and large straight. I'm playing way better than he is and he's destroying me - which is normal for yahtzee but he doesn't understand this. So I concede with 2 turns to go and he says ...
Poor sports concede games
What a goof. Calls me a poor sport but he's a sore winner. That's a 100% thumbs down. Learn to play before you spout off. Players who understand how the game works usually don't care if you concede.
I'm pro allowing people to concede and agree that the people repeatedly coming to the forums to complain about people conceding and giving players red thumbs for using a legitimate option to concede in a game where a win is mathematically certain at some point are the real problem, but your clear anger and frustration over someone else's luck really does make your conceding in this case seem like poor sportsmanship and like you conceded over losing to a player you seem to think didn't deserve to win.
User avatar
Semprini72
Posts: 34
Joined: 04 May 2026, 03:03

Re: Players conceding/resigning the game early

Post by Semprini72 »

RandomUN wrote: ↑16 November 2026, 16:36
Semprini72 wrote: ↑16 November 2026, 15:47 It's the anti-concede crowd that is the problem. They don't understand the math and they don't understand how the game works.

Just now, I just played against a very poor player with 100 elo. He made terrible decisions, going for inside straights and getting behind on top very badly. Goes for full house right away with 2-pair and of course hits it. Then he buttlucks a yahtzee on the 3rd turn and I'm still keeping up with him, and then he buttlucks 4 5s and 4 6s late in the game to get his top. I try open-ended TWICE for large straight and can't hit it. Now I can't catch him, he's like 90 pts ahead and I had to scratch my yahtzee and large straight. I'm playing way better than he is and he's destroying me - which is normal for yahtzee but he doesn't understand this. So I concede with 2 turns to go and he says ...
Poor sports concede games
What a goof. Calls me a poor sport but he's a sore winner. That's a 100% thumbs down. Learn to play before you spout off. Players who understand how the game works usually don't care if you concede.
I'm pro allowing people to concede and agree that the people repeatedly coming to the forums to complain about people conceding and giving players red thumbs for using a legitimate option to concede in a game where a win is mathematically certain at some point are the real problem, but your clear anger and frustration over someone else's luck really does make your conceding in this case seem like poor sportsmanship and like you conceded over losing to a player you seem to think didn't deserve to win.
No, you are wrong. I conceded because he was 90 pts up with 2 turns to go and I had already scratched yahtzee and large. I had no chance. THEN he takes a swipe at me in the chat. HE is the poor sport. He is the sore winner and the only thing that I might be upset over is that I had to put up with an insult.
Post Reply

Return to “Yahtzee”