Can guests lie about their initial whereabouts?

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Post Reply
User avatar
CherryGloom
Posts: 5
Joined: 26 September 2024, 20:54

Can guests lie about their initial whereabouts?

Post by CherryGloom »

Rules state that "The room where the MURDERER claims to have been at the time of the murder is the room they were originally in. From there, they left in search of the murder weapon and then headed to the Study to kill Mr. Walton." I took it as they are unable to lie about where they were before the murder occured. In one of my games (automatic info) the info that staff provided was inconsistent with the info that some suspects provided (attached file). Have I misunderstood the rules? Do innocent guests provide truthful info about their whereabouts before the murder, but the murderer can lie?
User avatar
CherryGloom
Posts: 5
Joined: 26 September 2024, 20:54

Re: Can guests lie about their initial whereabouts?

Post by CherryGloom »

I cannot attach a photo for some reason. Basically staff said that there were 3 people in the Vestibule, 1 in the Library. M claimed he was in the Living room, B and A - in Vestibule, G in Library, but C and S claimed they were in the Billiard room, and such positioning was not possible. C and S were a murder and an accomplice.
truewired
Posts: 21
Joined: 25 January 2026, 03:50

Re: Can guests lie about their initial whereabouts?

Post by truewired »

You're right, nobody lies about their starting room , and only the murderer makes the trip to the Study (not the accomplice if there is one)

The hints about how many people were in the room are based on the amount of people at the time of the murder, meaning not counting the murderer itself (which can create contradictions that help finding who the murderer is)
User avatar
izzyvonhoot
Posts: 5
Joined: 15 July 2025, 00:54

Re: Can guests lie about their initial whereabouts?

Post by izzyvonhoot »

As truewired mentioned, the killer is not included in the counts provided by staff, since they were not in the room at the time of the murder (they were in the Study). On higher difficulties with a possible accomplice, only the accomplice will claim they saw the murderer; staff and innocent guests will never make this claim.

Be cautious about the Berwick sisters though; they count as 2 guests when the staff make their reports, not 1. So in your example, the count of 3 people in vestibule is accurate, even though only 2 suspects were there.

Image
Post Reply

Return to “Awkward Guests: The Walton Case”