Last 3 tiles

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/#!bugs
Post Reply
User avatar
Gladki_Alex
Posts: 1
Joined: 03 February 2024, 15:17

Last 3 tiles

Post by Gladki_Alex »

three tiles to the end, the opponent places his tile, then I have to place my last one and it is the final tile.
he places his penultimate one, I have to place the last one, but I come across a tile that doesn’t fit anywhere (cccc)
and the opponent makes two last moves in a row, but I don’t make a move, is this correct?
User avatar
euklid314
Posts: 719
Joined: 06 April 2020, 22:56

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by euklid314 »

No this is an old and well known bug.

In BGA every player gets a new tile as soon as they finish their move. This is an incorrect implementation in any case that a player gets an extra move and there are not enough tiles left (extra moves occur, e.g., in your case with a not-placeable tile, or if the builder is triggered).

Since the bug has not been repaired in years it is just bad luck when it hits you...
User avatar
CraftyRaf
Posts: 17
Joined: 13 April 2014, 13:15

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by CraftyRaf »

Known bug, reported to BGA staff in a 1.5 hour long meeting in January 2024, together with a list of 20+ other features/bugs to improve the implementation of the game, collected from the best players in the world. The bug you mention is one of the big issues for competitive Carcassonne. At the moment the World Team Carcassonne Online Championships are being played. Imagine losing the title because of a bug like this... The meeting itself was very constructive, but we are still waiting for the first bug to get fixed.
User avatar
CraftyRaf
Posts: 17
Joined: 13 April 2014, 13:15

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by CraftyRaf »

Please upvote the corresponding bug report: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=36461
bananasplay
Posts: 168
Joined: 30 May 2018, 16:43

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by bananasplay »

CraftyRaf wrote: ↑17 July 2024, 22:38 Please upvote the corresponding bug report: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=36461
I've upvoted that one, but it's actually a duplicate of a much longer standing report: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=7601 , which was first reported in 2017(!).

...which means that BGA has let this issue sit unresolved for a total of 7 full years, meanwhile implementing "features" that no one has asked for and which make life worse (the latest one being the new garish and cluttered "welcome" page) for gamers on this site. *rolls eyes at BGA*
Please check my profile for a list of bugs that need upvotes so that BGA will maybe get around to fixing them.
User avatar
CraftyRaf
Posts: 17
Joined: 13 April 2014, 13:15

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by CraftyRaf »

My opponent was able to finish a 44 point city because of this nonsense!
https://boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=949178626
FrankJones
Posts: 2927
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by FrankJones »

What is supposed to happen if a player' final tile cannot be placed? I don't know the official rule. That's such a weird scenario; I would not have thought it possible.
User avatar
euklid314
Posts: 719
Joined: 06 April 2020, 22:56

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by euklid314 »

FrankJones wrote: ↑16 November 2026, 23:36 What is supposed to happen if a player' final tile cannot be placed? I don't know the official rule. That's such a weird scenario; I would not have thought it possible.
If the last tile cannot be placed you discard it and just lose one move. Bad luck.

If the last but one tile cannot be placed you discard it and play the last tile instead. But here there is a bug on BGA (and that was the starting point of this thread). Since the other player has already drawn the last tile before your move they will play the tile instead of you.

In real life they would need to pass on the tile to you - even if they had already drawn it. According to the rules you are entitled to play it because your previous tile could not be placed.
FrankJones
Posts: 2927
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: Last 3 tiles

Post by FrankJones »

That makes sense. I'm surprised a game as popular as Carcassonne has such a major bug.
Post Reply

Return to “Carcassonne”