dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Knibbeltje
Posts: 8
Joined: 07 September 2026, 22:05

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Knibbeltje »

Paddles wrote: ↑17 November 2026, 02:08
Knibbeltje wrote: ↑15 November 2026, 22:37 I totally accept that for an answer. I didn't know that integrity had been validated and for the record: I never claimed any sort of bias, it's just that random generated by a computer always feels differtent from real life. A little bit of googling tells me there's different types of RNG's. Which one does BGA use?
It's in the FAQ, https://boardgamearena.com/faq?anchor=f ... ing_random

Personally, I'd trust dice rolls from a properly-designed algorithm over most physical dice, partly because of imperfections in the dice but mainly because a lot of people - including regular gamers - are not particularly random at rolling dice under domestic gaming conditions. (I'm not claiming widespread cheating here, just ineffective rolling.)

"Properly-designed" is harder than it looks, which is why using a known-good library function is the only appropriate action, and naive attempts to "improve" the random number generator usually make it less random. I only have four years of university study in mathematics and computer science, that's not enough to create a good random number generator.
Sure, I assume a computer can create a more perfect dice than real life, it's just that if you're ignorant about the precise workings of RNG's (like me and probably most people) and you (think) you spot 'stuff' that's out of the ordinary statistically, you kinda start mistrusting it... So thanks for informing us.

I still haven't heard any good reasons, though for not having a second deck variant where there is just the one deck and not the mixed 2 decks with half the cards removed.. :D
User avatar
Silene
Posts: 1032
Joined: 23 October 2013, 17:50

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Silene »

Knibbeltje wrote: ↑18 November 2026, 00:11 I still haven't heard any good reasons, though for not having a second deck variant where there is just the one deck and not the mixed 2 decks with half the cards removed.. :D
not sure if you're asking (a) why bga doesn't have that or (b) why there is no such official variant.

for (a) the answer is simple: because bga doesn't allow house rules to be implemented. the dice deck as explained before is an official variant from the publisher while the simple variant, that you want, is not.

for (b) i can only guess: maybe publishers intention is to have a variant that just smoothens off the natural edges of the random distributions outcomes while still sticking somewhat close to the original catan idea that some numbers can be luckier than others and you can't know what's about to come.
Check out the Allround-League: https://boardgamearena.com/group?id=7870115 --> a league where you have matches of random games vs. other players in your group. Season 10 is running Oct. '26 - Feb. '27
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3836
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Jellby »

I want a variant without dice or cards, just a sequence of 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, ..., 11, 11, 12, 1, 2, 2... No surprises there, perfectly uniform (assuming the total number of turns is a multiple of 36), no complaints :D
User avatar
Shivaware
Posts: 376
Joined: 26 November 2012, 17:00

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Shivaware »

Jellby wrote: ↑18 November 2026, 19:17 I want a variant without dice or cards, just a sequence of 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, ..., 11, 11, 12, 1, 2, 2... No surprises there, perfectly uniform (assuming the total number of turns is a multiple of 36), no complaints :D
The 1 would be a bit surprising...
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3836
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Post by Jellby »

Indeed, but given the tone and the general quality of these threads, I'll not even bother correcting it :D
Post Reply

Return to “Catan”