Private (voice) Chat with partner OK?

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Post Reply
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Private (voice) Chat with partner OK?

Post by huangsen »

Background story
Some days ago, one of the top player in ELO ranking wanted to invite me to a game with his/her (will be referred to as them for short) preset partner. During the inviting chat, they leaked that they have private voice chat with this partner and they usually do this while playing Tichu.

This inspires me for the following question:
  • Is it OK to have a private chat with partner during Tichu game?
  • Is having a private chat with partner during Tichu game cheating?
  • What would a private chat affect in a Tichu game possibly?
  • Can people be informed that players are having private chat before the gamr and choose to avoid them if they want to?
First of all
This is Not a cheating accusation. please don't ask me about any proof of cheating because it is not a cheating accusation. This is a discussion of whether private chat is a proper thing to do in a Tichu game.
And i hope everyone can find their way to enjoy playing Tichu :)
Last edited by huangsen on 20 November 2026, 06:52, edited 4 times in total.
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by huangsen »

As you have probably noticed, this is a reformulation of my other topic in this forum (viewtopic.php?t=52370), where people keep asking me proof of cheating. So please, you are kindly asked to read the topic before you reply here. Thank you.
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by huangsen »

If you would allow me, here is my point of view. (if you don't allow me to share my opinion, please don't watch the following. If you already watched, feel free to share your opinion below if you want to and remember agree to disagree :) )
  • Private chat is not necessarily cheating but could be an not-intended implicit hidden message exchanger
as someone pointed out that a private chat can be about wheather and not related to the game. However, take myself as an example, i speak less when i was sad because maybe i got bad hand in game. so this could leak some hidden information about your hand.

about other items in list, will write more later
silentProtest
Posts: 253
Joined: 26 March 2022, 20:12

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by silentProtest »

huangsen wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 03:52

This inspires me for the following question:
  • Is it OK to have a private chat with partner during Tichu game?
  • Is having a private chat with partner during Tichu game cheating?
  • What would a private chat affect in a Tichu game possibly?
  • Can people be informed that players are having private chat before the gamr and choose to avoid them if they want to?
straight forward questions, straight forward answers:
- yes, why not. As long as no information AT ALL about the game is shared. that goes also for shared chats like table chat ... (I insta block people that try to share information about hand in PNs, and share those names peer-to-peer so to say...)
- it depends, see above. Some have just a chat about live in table chat. wouldnt see any problems if the same is done via PNs.
- It SHOULD affect nothing! ... if youre asking about cheat tips, it could affect anything. but why use chat or voicechat at all? just use any software with screenshare... (but esp now, with experimental play... it IS quite visible if partners are aware of each others hand; that being said, imo, the better the players the better they could actually hide it. BUT why play at all then? Esp here, where you mostly only find noob teams if you play with fixed partner....)
- it is to your own discretion who you avoid. I block anything under 55% win rate in tichu. I dont want them neither in my, nor in opponent team.... and I havent seen anything forbidding sharing information in chats (or maybe even groups(?)). forums on the other hand are forbidden - pretty sure the reasons are things like stupid witch hunts, based on flawed or false information....

a comment about your backstory. I think you thought youre being honey potted in a potentially cheating table, because they PNed you directly. (and weird behaviour after from your POV..) - my first impulse why you were PNed is cause of your good stats -> good player, and they just went through ranking list by who is online and good to challenge (because destroying bad players is prob not too enjoyable, esp. compared to a competitive game! ;) )
silentProtest
Posts: 253
Joined: 26 March 2022, 20:12

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by silentProtest »

huangsen wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 04:16
  • Private chat is not necessarily cheating but could be an not-intended implicit hidden message exchanger
very fair point, because in voice chat you could guess some information based on intonation, in some situations. Maybe something to think about.
but it doesnt extend to written chat in my opinion. And in table chat same information can be conveyed: When you have to think about something and ask for time, to not be kicked, or if you literally think about something for a minute or so ... all kind of things can be picked up through timings, esp with people you play often with/against...
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by huangsen »

First of all, thank you for your reply. Your points is fair and nicely expressed
silentProtest wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 08:46 straight forward questions, straight forward answers:
- yes, why not. As long as no information AT ALL about the game is shared. that goes also for shared chats like table chat ... (I insta block people that try to share information about hand in PNs, and share those names peer-to-peer so to say...)
Yes. Though i'm afraid that it is unlikely the case in private voice/video chat or screen sharing. As i said in my example, there will almost definitely be hidden informations carried in speed of speaking etc. and they are shared privately deliberatedly or not.
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by huangsen »

silentProtest wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 08:46 - It SHOULD affect nothing! ... if youre asking about cheat tips, it could affect anything. but why use chat or voicechat at all? just use any software with screenshare... (but esp now, with experimental play... it IS quite visible if partners are aware of each others hand; that being said, imo, the better the players the better they could actually hide it. BUT why play at all then? Esp here, where you mostly only find noob teams if you play with fixed partner....)
YES IT SHOULD
(it's not a cheating tip but) what about this, some may decide to bet grand tichu bet depending on both their and their partner's cards. and you can just say or hint in the private voice chat that "i have good cards" or "lucky today" or "today's weather is so good" or just screen share or whatever. Then you bet grand tichu and your partner happened to have a bomb or pass you a dragon or something like that.

Is this cheating? Even if experimental play can make it visible, why it can't be just a risky try? :P
huangsen
Posts: 15
Joined: 19 July 2026, 05:43

Re: Is Private Chat with partner OK

Post by huangsen »

silentProtest wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 08:46 a comment about your backstory. I think you thought youre being honey potted in a potentially cheating table, because they PNed you directly. (and weird behaviour after from your POV..) - my first impulse why you were PNed is cause of your good stats -> good player, and they just went through ranking list by who is online and good to challenge (because destroying bad players is prob not too enjoyable, esp. compared to a competitive game! ;) )
yes i think i was honey potted. thank you for pointing out the other possibility. But i still tend to think the sneaky way, unless they have nothing to do and waste minutes scrolling down the list to find me. i'm not ahead on the ranking list. i mostly play friendly mode and random teaming, and they didn't even join my table and they kept asking me to do with their settings until they leaked and i refused to play

but after all, it's not an accusation and no accusations here. Thank you for your thoughts here @silentprotest
Post Reply

Return to “Tichu”